Judge orders arbitration for Crown, FLS

News Story
- 4 Jun 2004 ( #160 ) - DAYTON, OH, United States
2 min read
Crown Equipment Corporation's litigation against dealer Florida Lift Systems Inc (FLS) is working its way through arbitration en route to a possible US District Court trial in Dayton.

Judge Walter Herbert Rice directed Crown and FLS to arbitrate their differences and jointly report on the status by June 25.

Crown is seeking to terminate FLS as a Crown dealer (Forkliftaction.com News #144), and FLS has sued Crown (Forkliftaction.com News #149). Earlier, Crown had declared unilaterally that it would terminate FLS on June 1. Judge Rice granted an FLS request for a temporary order against Crown implementing the termination.

"The court agreed with Crown's position and enforced the arbitration provision of the dealer agreement and compelled the parties to arbitrate their differences," said John Maxa, Crown vice-president and general counsel, in a letter to Crown dealers. The court directed that "Crown cannot effect a termination prior to June 25," Mr Maxa acknowledged.

FLS attorney Hugh Bode, of Reminger & Reminger Co LPA, in Cleveland, Ohio, had strong views.

"The court's decision requiring FLS and Crown to arbitrate their dispute recognised the inconsistency of the aggressive litigation strategy Crown has employed against FLS," he said. "The court chastised Crown for claiming the right to unilaterally terminate FLS after Crown had commenced litigation and requested arbitration to determine the 'lawfulness' of termination."

Mr Bode also represents Toyota Material Handling USA Inc (TMHU), of Irvine, California, in separate but related litigation in a Toledo, Ohio, federal court. Crown's lawsuit says TMHU caused FLS to breach its Crown dealer agreement.

In April, TMHU filed a counterclaim against Crown, alleging intentional interference with a contract, interference with a business relationship, abuse of process and anti-trust violations.

On the Crown versus FLS case, Mr Bode said "fair, unbiased arbitration gives FLS the opportunity to be heard. The issues to be addressed in arbitration are the same as the issues that would be heard in a court of law. We are certain that a fair arbitration proceeding will reflect positively on FLS."

FLS has been a Crown distributor for 18 years and, for the past five years, says it has produced a 40%-plus market share for Crown in its territory. FLS has annual sales of more than USD40 million.

"Crown's behaviour is totally out of character from the Crown I thought I knew," Jeff Fischer, FLS chief executive officer, said. "With Crown's total sales of USD1 billion, I can't understand how our effort to become a stronger dealer in the IC classes that Crown does not make poses any threat to Crown."

FLS began representing TMHU in Orlando in September 2002 and became a TMHU dealer in Tampa in January 2004.
Clark names two new US distributors
Clark names two new US distributors 22 May 2025 - Dallas, TX, United States - 1 min read
Court reduces forklift accident fine
Court reduces forklift accident fine 18 Jul 2024 - Birmingham, United Kingdom - 1 min read
Previously about:
Crown launches pedestrian pallet truck series News Story - 3 Jul 2025 - Munich, Germany - 1 min read
Crown launches new C-B Series counterbalance forklift News Story - 3 Oct 2024 - New Bremen, OH, United States - 1 min read
Winners of 2024 Archies Awards named News Story - 19 Sep 2024 - Birmingham, United Kingdom - 1 min read
Arbitration confirmed; Crown v Toyota continues News Story - 23 Mar 2005 - Dayton, OH, United States - 1 min read
Crown plans Florida branch as FLS arbitration nears News Story - 19 Aug 2004 - DAYTON, OH, United States - 3 min read
SOUTHERN STATES TOYOTALIFT JOINS TMHU NETWORK News Story - 20 May 2004 - IRVINE, CA, United States - 1 min read
Crown plans Florida branch as FLS arbitration nears News Story - 19 Aug 2004 - DAYTON, OH, United States - 3 min read
FLS SUES CROWN IN DEALERSHIP WAR News Story - 18 Mar 2004 - TAMPA, FL, United States - 3 min read
CROWN SUES FLORIDA LIFT SYSTEMS, TMHU News Story - 12 Feb 2004 - NEW BREMEN, OH, United States - 3 min read
Crown plans Florida branch as FLS arbitration nears News Story - 19 Aug 2004 - DAYTON, OH, United States - 3 min read
FLS SUES CROWN IN DEALERSHIP WAR News Story - 18 Mar 2004 - TAMPA, FL, United States - 3 min read
CROWN SUES FLORIDA LIFT SYSTEMS, TMHU News Story - 12 Feb 2004 - NEW BREMEN, OH, United States - 3 min read
Toyota completes North American integration News Story - 9 Jan 2020 - Columbus, IN, United States - 1 min read
Product News News Story - 19 Jul 2018 - 2 min read
Toyota sells hand pallet trucks online News Story - 26 Apr 2018 - Columbus, IN, United States - 1 min read
Briefs News Story - 15 May 2025 - 2 min read
Toyota moves to settle US emissions case News Story - 24 Apr 2025 - San Francisco, CA, United States - 2 min read
Toyota names North American leadership team News Story - 17 Apr 2025 - Columbus, IN, United States - 2 min read
Do you have materials handling news? Submit your news here

PREMIUM business

RAEDER-VOGEL
Innovative high-quality wheels and castors for the forklift industry.

Since July 2000, Forkliftaction News has been your guide to the developments that are shaping your industry.

Starting today we are also looking back on some of the key news stories from our extensive news archive.

In the news email and on the website, you'll see links to stories that were 'leading our news' multiple years ago, with topics spanning world-first products, big acquisitions, and major industry shifts.
We hope you enjoy this unique insight into the materials handling industry!

Words of support …

These releases in Forkliftaction are a nice experience for SNDC... We got seven inquiries coming from Canada, USA, Mexico, Israel and Australia (five from retailers, two from machines manufacturers) and we are still in contact with them. I can state that's a success story!

David Massat, Sales Director OEM and Export

Are you recruiting? Find your ideal candidate among a diverse range of materials handling professionals:

Forkliftaction's JOB MARKET

Since July 2000, Forkliftaction News has been your guide to the developments that are shaping your industry.

Starting today we are also looking back on some of the key news stories from our extensive news archive.

In the news email and on the website, you'll see links to stories that were 'leading our news' multiple years ago, with topics spanning world-first products, big acquisitions, and major industry shifts.
We hope you enjoy this unique insight into the materials handling industry!

Are you recruiting? Find your ideal candidate among a diverse range of materials handling professionals:

Forkliftaction's JOB MARKET

It’s the year 2000. You’re in front of a boxy beige desktop waiting for the screeching ramblings of your dial-up to reach its finale. You go to Yahoo!, MSN, or maybe AOL, and start the mind-numbing process of finding your very specific needle in the digital haystack. And with web pages loading one image at a time, patience isn’t just a virtue – it’s a requirement!

As clumsy as this early iteration seems now, this technology was the great enabler that allowed Forkliftaction to connect to the industry across the globe.  

To everyone who has connected with Forkliftaction in the past 25 years, thank you for your contribution to our success! We feel deeply touched by your words of encouragement.

What has Forkliftaction meant to you? Drop us a line.