Discussion:
Catalytic Converter

I have a Yale GLC050VXNVSE083 unit that was sent to a local shop in Houston, TX for repairs. When the unit was returned, there wasn't enough power to drive it up the ramp into the warehouse, even though the unit was supposedly tested and deemed ready to be returned to service. The driver for the shop took it back for further testing. Have had to wait several weeks for a Yale rep to unlock the unit to clear some codes and get some additional information. It was determined that the cause of the lack of power is a clogged Catalytic Converter. The estimate for parts and labor is $1550.00. There were no previous indications or codes related to issues with the catalytic converter. Should there have been codes? What can cause it to be clogged? I store the unit in a warehouse, but while at the shop, it was stored in an open lot, which caused the forks to rust. Is $1550 for parts and labor reasonable? We've already paid close to $6000 for other repairs and a rental unit, so this will push it over $8000. We may need to consider getting a new forklift, and dumping our current service company.

Thanks.
  • Posted 12 Jan 2017 11:32
  • By OfcMgrFloors
  • joined 12 Jan'17 - 2 messages
  • Texas, United States
Showing items 1 - 7 of 7 results.
All that repair work and PM work could of been done onsite...the only thing we ever sent back to the shop was engine or transmission
swaps/replace......and that with working out of just a GM 2500 service van and nott some big truck
  • Posted 4 Mar 2017 08:32
  • Modified 4 Mar 2017 08:33 by poster
  • By kevin_t
  • joined 2 Dec'10 - 1,301 messages
  • Pennsylvania, United States
BBforks/kevin_t - There was a hydraulic fluid leak, several codes and it was time for some standard PM. It took them 11 days to determine that the tilt cylinders were bad, and that was after they had replaced hoses at the fork cylinder and added 2 gallons of hyraulic oil (because it had leaked all over my warehouse floor). They also replaced some gaskets, and the air and oil filters. It was another 7 days (not including weekends) for them to complete the tilt cylinder repair, and just as they were ready to return the unit, they finally spotted the the No Trans Braking & Temp Light codes. I had to tell him it may be related to the Tiss/Toss sensor. They were going to return the unit without clearing the codes since they couldn't unlock it. They said they were told that the those codes would not affect the performace of the unit. When they finally transported the unit back to my warehouse, the unit didn't have enough power to even drive up the ramp, in spite of the Service Manager's statement that he personally tested it before sending it back. They claim that sometime during transport, the cat got clogged.

Brewski, you are correct that they were not authorized Yale dealers and yes, we did get taken. I actually went back through 18 months of invoices and noted several instances of inconsistent billing practices. I turned it all over to my company's owner, who told them they could just keep the Yale. We have since purchased a new Toyota forklift, with a service contract, and will no longer do any business with this company. I don't know what was resolved, but I haven't seen the Yale since.

I am new to the world of forklifts (and a female), and appreciate the responses. Information is a powerful tool.

Thanks.
  • Posted 4 Mar 2017 08:26
  • By OfcMgrFloors
  • joined 12 Jan'17 - 2 messages
  • Texas, United States
What was the lifts issue in the first place that the company had to take it to their shop to work on it?....unless it was a MAJOR repair all work can be done on site if the customer. Has the room and time,i have done everything from changing head gaskets and timing components to rebuilding masts onsite......

i would definately be looking for a diffrent service company,sounds likemyour current one is taking you for a ride...
  • Posted 4 Mar 2017 07:50
  • By kevin_t
  • joined 2 Dec'10 - 1,301 messages
  • Pennsylvania, United States
It seems you took it to a non Yale dealer for repair. Several weeks to wait for a rep is ridiculous. Any of our service techs can plug in to a truck and retrieve codes. In the last 13 years we have had two plugged converters. these were on trucks that where neglected and fault codes ignored. Unless you had major mast repair or engine/ transmission work done you got taken. Sorry but its a fact.
  • Posted 4 Mar 2017 06:58
  • By BREWSKI
  • joined 10 Jan'12 - 1,699 messages
  • Nebraska, United States
I stand corrected on the price of the cat. I've paid $1200.00 for a cat ( not this model) so i assumed ( incorrectly) that all cats were over $1000.00. The one i replaced had only 7000 hrs on it. The customer tried to get warranty but was rejected because of not using the specified HD-5 fuel.

As far as the wait time & price of other repair, what was wrong with the lift?
  • Posted 4 Mar 2017 06:57
  • Modified 4 Mar 2017 06:57 by poster
  • By bbforks
  • joined 1 Mar'12 - 1,437 messages
  • Pennsylvania, United States
bbforks (at) Hotmail (dot) com
Customers love technology- until they have to pay to fix it!
It drives me nuts to read posts like this. $6000 for what? You got it back and it had no power? Several weeks to unlock and read codes? It is just crazy. I'll say it, "they don't know what they're doing and you're getting ripped off". List price on a cat is between $550 and $850 depending on what year you have. I service 2 of these models with 37000 hours and they have been through **** but they have the proper power and original cats. I don't know what's wrong with yours but this is way out of line. Sending the lift back from the shop and saying "there you go, you're all set" proves they don't have a clue. Rant over.
  • Posted 4 Mar 2017 06:42
  • By mrfixit
  • joined 11 Dec'08 - 1,434 messages
  • New York, United States
What was the lift sent to the shop for originally? I can't think of anything the service company could have done to clog the cat-cats clog from impurities in the fuel (not using HD-5 grade fuel), overheating the cat (running the engine with a faulty cylinder) or physical deterioration (banging around from rough terrain, etc).

The quote doesn't seem excessive as cats are quite expensive- unlike a car where you can get generic cats- the cat for your lift is specific to only a few models- so when sales volume goes down, price goes up.

As far as buying a new lift- just understand that newer lifts (2004 & newer) are full of electronics which are expensive to maintain.
  • Posted 4 Mar 2017 04:31
  • By bbforks
  • joined 1 Mar'12 - 1,437 messages
  • Pennsylvania, United States
bbforks (at) Hotmail (dot) com
Customers love technology- until they have to pay to fix it!

Post your Reply

Forkliftaction accepts no responsibility for forum content and requires forum participants to adhere to our rules of conduct. Click here for more information.

If you are having trouble using the Discussion Forums, please contact us for help.

Fact of the week
Bluetooth is named after the 10th-century Viking king, Harald Bluetooth, who united warring tribes in Denmark and Norway. In 1997, Jim Kardach from Intel gave the name to the technology because of its ability to unite different communication protocols, just as Harald united various tribes.
Latest job alerts …
Harrisburg, SD, United States
Ottumwa, IA, United States
Wentzville, MO, United States
Upcoming industry events …
July 22-24, 2025 - Sydney, Australia
November 11-13, 2025 - Singapore, Singapore
November 12-13, 2025 - London, United Kingdom
Global Industry News
edition #1235 - 19 June 2025
Greek philosopher Heraclitus is credited with the famous saying “change is the only constant”, and this week’s Forkliftaction News demonstrates this is certainly true in the case of the materials handling sector... Continue reading
Fact of the week
Bluetooth is named after the 10th-century Viking king, Harald Bluetooth, who united warring tribes in Denmark and Norway. In 1997, Jim Kardach from Intel gave the name to the technology because of its ability to unite different communication protocols, just as Harald united various tribes.