Lessons from automation failure

News Story
- 6 Oct 2022 ( #1097 ) - Auckland, New Zealand
1 min read
Automation testing at Auckland harbour
Automation testing at Auckland harbour

There are several key recommendations following Ports of Auckland’s failed automation project.

An independent report into the failure found inadequate input from senior management and a lack of engagement from managers.

The report recommends that trusted employees who intimately understand the organisation's business must be included when a team is established to evaluate a business problem and potential solutions. 

It also recommends that the person appointed to lead a project must have the right qualifications for the role, in light of the particular project at hand, and have the necessary interpersonal skills to lead a cross-functional team.

The report by Mark Binns was scathing about the vendor selection, and the recommendations call for “a structured process for vendor selection … with the criteria upon which the selection is to be made established and agreed and any necessary additional safeguards implemented so that the selection is objectively supportable”.

The report notes that former directors remain firmly of the opinion that the project should not have been terminated. “It is not within the scope of the review to form a view on whether the decision to terminate was correct or not, although the current board's decision to terminate the project based on the two independent reports it had commissioned is understandable,” Binns concludes.

As reported in July, an independent review was initiated after Ports of Auckland dumped its automation project after six years of failing to fully implement it, writing off NZD65 million in the process.

Dematic automates Turkish distribution centre
Dematic automates Turkish distribution centre 1 May 2025 - Istanbul, Turkey - 1 min read
LogiMAT 2025 and automation
LogiMAT 2025 and automation 3 Apr 2025 - Stuttgart, Germany - 4 min read
Is data the greatest lost opportunity for our sector?
Is data the greatest lost opportunity for our sector? 27 Mar 2025 - Chicago, IL, United States - 3 min read
Previously about:
Auckland port automation failure News Story - 3 Dec 2020 - Auckland, New Zealand - 1 min read
CLARK AUSTRALIA IN MAJOR NOELL STRADDLE DEAL News Story - 12 Sep 2002 - AUCKLAND, New Zealand - 1 min read
Do you have materials handling news? Submit your news here

PREMIUM business

Cascade Corporation (World HQ)
Leading manufacturers of attachments, forks and related technologies for forklifts and AGVs.

Even the heaviest lifts must be easy to handle. That’s why N.C. Nielsen raises the bar in lifting capacity, maneuverability, operator comfort, flexibility and technical capabilities.
Heavy duty reach stackers – lifting capacity from 85 to 180 tons.
VIEW ALL OUR CUSTOM-BUILT HEAVY DUTY REACH STACKERS

Contact us now: +45 99 83 83 83 - www.nc-nielsen.com

Words of support …

Undoubtedly, peer experience plays a crucially important role in our industry and it is extremely valuable for us to be part of the platform, where industry professionals, as well as end users can discuss and learn more about the materials handling world.

Alexandra Artemova, Marketing Specialist - Rocla AGV Solutions

Are you recruiting? Find your ideal candidate among a diverse range of materials handling professionals:

Forkliftaction's JOB MARKET

Transparent, effective, accountable. With Forkliftaction advertising you will know exactly what to expect before the start of your next campaign.

Tell us your objectives and we’ll propose a competitively priced, brand-centred campaign with your CPM* fixed at the campaign’s start. Geo-targeted campaigns available!

For audience statistics and a concise overview of our advertising offer DOWNLOAD our Media Kit.

* CPM = Cost-Per-Thousand impressions 

Inside The News
In this week’s Forkliftaction News we look at the financial reports of some of the materials handling industry’s largest players including Hyster-Yale, KION and Hangcha... Continue reading

Are you recruiting? Find your ideal candidate among a diverse range of materials handling professionals:

Forkliftaction's JOB MARKET

Inside The News
In this week’s Forkliftaction News we look at the financial reports of some of the materials handling industry’s largest players including Hyster-Yale, KION and Hangcha... Continue reading

PREMIUM business

Flexi® By Narrow Aisle Limited
Leading manufacturers of very narrow aisle (VNA) equipment.

Are you recruiting? Find your ideal candidate among a diverse range of materials handling professionals:

Forkliftaction's JOB MARKET

Even the heaviest lifts must be easy to handle. That’s why N.C. Nielsen raises the bar in lifting capacity, maneuverability, operator comfort, flexibility and technical capabilities.
Heavy duty reach stackers – lifting capacity from 85 to 180 tons.
VIEW ALL OUR CUSTOM-BUILT HEAVY DUTY REACH STACKERS

Contact us now: +45 99 83 83 83 - www.nc-nielsen.com