Discussion:
Counterbalance V Reach

Hi,
In Ireland where I was trained as an instructor there was a separate license for reach trucks and counterbalance, but here in Australia you only need one licence to cover both.
In my opinion the counterbalance truck and the reach truck are two different machines which require two different licenses.
What do you think?
  • Posted 23 Apr 2009 13:30
  • By paddyB
  • joined 23 Apr'09 - 51 messages
  • Queensland, Australia
In 20 years time people will regret what they didn't do rather than what they did.
Showing items 1 - 17 of 17 results.
paddyB,
If government employees down under are like those in the States you often get a resposne from an uninformed individual who "thinks" they have the correct answer or your call to them interrupted a "text messaging" session they were having and jsut wanted to blow you off so tehy could get back to doing something they are not paid to do.

My suggest to CYA is contact them one again and get the response from them in writing, pass on to your companies management and keep a copy in your personal file.

It seems to me Austrialia is much more progressive than the response you received.
  • Posted 19 May 2009 02:55
  • By johnr_j
  • joined 3 Jun'06 - 1,452 messages
  • Georgia, United States
"Have An Exceptional Day!"
Thanks for the response guys,
i did ask the question here in oz but the response from the OHS was that they didnt think there was a need to seperate both.
i'm in a new warehouse where i have to assess licences drivers, but when i ask them about their experience, they tell me they have never operated a reach truck before. then im asked the question why i want to give them more training?????
  • Posted 18 May 2009 21:02
  • By paddyB
  • joined 23 Apr'09 - 51 messages
  • Queensland, Australia
Paddy,
It seems that teh UK & US have a more defined requiredment for employers to "qualifiy or certify" forklfit operators than those from Australia. Maybe it is because of our "lawyers".

Have you made a comparison of what the UK's, Health & Safety at Work Act and the US, Occumational Safety & Health Acts state vs what Australia has published? That might help you.
With the internet you should be able to find this. From the US stand point "Clark" Material Handling Company makes a nice publication for Employers on this subject - I'll try to find the exact name and publication number for you.
  • Posted 15 May 2009 22:03
  • By johnr_j
  • joined 3 Jun'06 - 1,452 messages
  • Georgia, United States
"Have An Exceptional Day!"
In the UK, we believe that there are sufficient operating differences between a counterbalanced lift truck and a reach truck to justify a separate certificate of basic training. In a similar manner, there is a sufficient difference between a counterbalanced truck and, say, a pivot-steer truck. In each case there is a separate training course supporting specific certificates of basic training. There are recommended routes to convert from one to the other that allows for existing skills to be varied to encompass the new requirements. This has worked well for some 30-odd years.

There is no lift truck licence in the UK and, according to my sources in HSE, there never will be. This is due to the fact that there would need to be a change to the Health and Safety at Work Act to encomapass this as provision for licencing is not included withoin its scope.
  • Posted 15 May 2009 01:55
  • By DaveP
  • joined 7 Apr'09 - 6 messages
  • Somerset, United Kingdom
Hey Guys,
by the way as a matter of interest, what are your views on the question i asked at the start?
  • Posted 28 Apr 2009 09:31
  • By paddyB
  • joined 23 Apr'09 - 51 messages
  • Queensland, Australia
In 20 years time people will regret what they didn't do rather than what they did.
Heading for a few this evening....... u have the weather we have the guinness......trow another shrimp on the barbie
  • Posted 26 Apr 2009 00:39
  • By DAMO
  • joined 9 Jan'07 - 196 messages
  • DUBLIN, Ireland
sadly the REAL waterford crystal is no more, if you have some hold onto it because its machine made now in germany or somewhere like that. not hand crafted like it was in waterford.
Damo, work is going good down here, but its starting to slow down. hopefully the economy will recover very soon.

jeyeas i'd love a real pint of guinness now.
  • Posted 25 Apr 2009 20:09
  • By paddyB
  • joined 23 Apr'09 - 51 messages
  • Queensland, Australia
In 20 years time people will regret what they didn't do rather than what they did.
HY PADDY HOWS THE WORK GOING OVER THERE STAYED UP IN BARRACK STREET WATERFORD LAST WEEK ,,,,
  • Posted 25 Apr 2009 08:09
  • By DAMO
  • joined 9 Jan'07 - 196 messages
  • DUBLIN, Ireland
I'm almost certain it is - that's why they drop it very slowly to the final count down from 10 to 0 (12 teh New Year) and then everyone gets Irish again - lot of kissing , hugging and consumption of pints (we do that twice a year - St. Paddy's Day & that's an all day affair w/green beer & green rivers, especially in Chicago. I understand Waterford is not in good financial shape these days. Maybe they can speed up the drop and create some business for them.
  • Posted 25 Apr 2009 05:08
  • By johnr_j
  • joined 3 Jun'06 - 1,452 messages
  • Georgia, United States
"Have An Exceptional Day!"
that ball that drops every year, would that be a waterford crystal ball? as in waterford ireland?
  • Posted 24 Apr 2009 11:52
  • By paddyB
  • joined 23 Apr'09 - 51 messages
  • Queensland, Australia
Good for you and your family. That's what this is all about.

Been a bit of a nomad myself - We have moved to six different cities in my career. This is our last stop - I hope.

You know Austrailia and Georgia, US have a lot in common - King George - he sent the real bad guys went to "down under" We still like Mel Gibson and Quigley & the Aussie New Year's celebration a lot more intersting than watching a ball drop in the same place every year. PlusI can bring in the New Year with y'all at 9:00 AM my time & go to bed "happy" at 9:00 PM. lol

Keep a stiff upper lip!

Regards
  • Posted 24 Apr 2009 11:16
  • By johnr_j
  • joined 3 Jun'06 - 1,452 messages
  • Georgia, United States
"Have An Exceptional Day!"
hi Johnr j
My signature line is about taking that chance that comes around maybe once in a lifetime.
In my case I immigrated to Australia from a city called Waterford in Ireland with my family of wife and 2 kids, giving up a very good job, house etc. and people at home though I was mad, BUT Australia is fantastic and we as a family have never been happier. (Thank you Australia)
  • Posted 24 Apr 2009 09:19
  • By paddyB
  • joined 23 Apr'09 - 51 messages
  • Queensland, Australia
In 20 years time people will regret what they didn't do rather than what they did.
paddy8
I concurr with your thoughts on operator training. But can't quite agree with your signature line. In my case, I worked in this industry 41 years, now retired, I can honestly say I have never regretted it - it was fun, hard work, long hours most of the time. But had the opportunities to travel to 42 of our 50 states, visit 5 different countries- never to"down under", left a little legacy along the way, met some fine people and made some close & still close friends - that ain't bad. Now I made room for a least one younger guy to get similar opportunities.

C Ya Mate!
  • Posted 24 Apr 2009 08:33
  • By johnr_j
  • joined 3 Jun'06 - 1,452 messages
  • Georgia, United States
"Have An Exceptional Day!"
hi,
Can you say the same about cars and motor bikes i.e. the same principle applies? Same rules of the road etc.
We all know that both machines handle differently, they turn differently, they have different rules etc e.g. on a counterbalance you are instructed to have the seatbelt on and stay within the safety cab in case of a rollover BUT with the reach you are told to step off the machine in case of a rollover because there is no seatbelt (well there's no seat belts on any of the 25 reach trucks we have here)
I think too many people don't take forklift training and the dangers involved seriously enough (I'm talking about some employers) and trainers should leave nothing to chance. Trainers should never assume that trainees will show common sense, they should insist the rules and procedures are followed to the letter. Have you ever heard the saying that common sense is not very common!

I do agree unit and on site familiarization training is important, but so is giving trainees the opportunity to train in a controlled environment and teaching the basics on the specific machine they will be using in their workplace.
  • Posted 24 Apr 2009 08:06
  • By paddyB
  • joined 23 Apr'09 - 51 messages
  • Queensland, Australia
In 20 years time people will regret what they didn't do rather than what they did.
In the US the owner of the company/employer is required by OSHA to provide training for the functions an operator is to be performed - eg loading/receiving dock, warehousing, production support, etc. These are to be company management supervised in a "simulated enviroment" and not "on the job training" where other employees are present. Accordingly, the type of equipment used can be widely different - counterbalance sit down or stand up, pantograph or mast reach, walkie types, order selectors, turret truck s etc. It is obvious that each of these type "do not" operate on the same principles and training for each needs to be provided. The empoyer needs to keep a file on each operator of the type of equipment that they have been certified to operate and the work enviroment they have been qualifed to work in.

In the end it is the employer that makes the final decision who is granted a certifcate. The forklift dealer can support the training by conduction training class on principles of operation of the various equipment types etc, or provide train the trainer programs or supply training materials

That's the law in a nutshell - in actual practice you'll find employers that do comply and others who do little or nothing or some like to call "risk management"
  • Posted 23 Apr 2009 21:12
  • By johnr_j
  • joined 3 Jun'06 - 1,452 messages
  • Georgia, United States
"Have An Exceptional Day!"
Guys don't confuse "certificates of basic training" and Licenses. I do not pretend to know the situation down under but across Europe the requirement legally is for Basic Training.
  • Posted 23 Apr 2009 17:54
  • By Normandy
  • joined 28 Sep'06 - 186 messages
  • Co. Cork, Ireland
I think in the UK, there is too much training where logic and common sense should prevail.
All forklifts work on the same principle, work in different enviroments and locations but still do the same operation.
I think unit and site familiarisation is more important than having to get a separate licence when a person already knows how to drive and operate a truck in a responsible manner.
I have seen where youngsters and older persons alike have done a course and obtained licences for forklift trucks yet have not actually worked in a production enviroment.
This has led to some accidents when they have started work as they were not taught how to drive the units in an actual production enviroment.
I have an operators licence for all trucks as I used to work on them but the test and course to obtain the licence was all done on a flat surface and in a controlled enviroment.

My personal verdict is, one licence should be sufficient as long as the individual has the sense and responsibility to operate one in the first place
  • Posted 23 Apr 2009 17:25
  • By derek_h
  • joined 13 Nov'04 - 28 messages
  • S.Yorks, United Kingdom

Post your Reply

Forkliftaction accepts no responsibility for forum content and requires forum participants to adhere to our rules of conduct. Click here for more information.

If you are having trouble using the Discussion Forums, please contact us for help.

Hangcha CPYD30XH21
Flesherton, Ontario, Canada
New - Sale
Toyota 3FD100
Yokohama, Japan
Used - Sale
Upcoming industry events …
October 29-31, 2025 - Marina Bay Sands, Singapore
November 13-14, 2025 - Berlin, Germany
March 10-12, 2026 - Hong Kong, Hong Kong
Global Industry News
edition #1245 - 28 August 2025
In this week’s Forkliftaction News , we look at MHEDA’s Q3 Economic Advisory Report which reveals current resilience in the US materials handling sector... Continue reading
Hangcha CPYD30XH21
Flesherton, Ontario, Canada
New - Sale
Toyota 3FD100
Yokohama, Japan
Used - Sale
Upcoming industry events …
October 29-31, 2025 - Marina Bay Sands, Singapore
November 13-14, 2025 - Berlin, Germany
March 10-12, 2026 - Hong Kong, Hong Kong
Movers & Shakers
Steve Dimitrovski Steve Dimitrovski
Director sales for Australia and New Zealand, Swisslog
General Manager, Forkpro Australia
Global CEO, Swisslog
Board member, UKMHA
Upcoming industry events …
October 29-31, 2025 - Marina Bay Sands, Singapore
November 13-14, 2025 - Berlin, Germany
March 10-12, 2026 - Hong Kong, Hong Kong
Latest job alerts …
Dallas, TX or Lexington, KY, United States
Tampa, United States
Marietta, United States
Tampa/Orlando Florida, United States
Movers & Shakers
Steve Dimitrovski Steve Dimitrovski
Director sales for Australia and New Zealand, Swisslog
General Manager, Forkpro Australia
Global CEO, Swisslog
Board member, UKMHA