Discussion:
Help me please forklift advise

I'm buying 3 wheel forklift 3K-3.5k capacity.
Have 3 quotes. DOOSAN, Model #: B18T-5 36V for $25,8000, Crown SC5220-30 for $26,988, Komatsu TCM FTB16-7 for $29,430.

Please let me know which is best. Should I look for Cat, Yale, Hyster, or Hyundai?

I really appreciate any advice.
  • Posted 1 Jan 2013 12:14
  • Modified 1 Jan 2013 12:18 by poster
  • Discussion started by Natan
  • New Jersey, United States
Live right
Showing items 1 - 15 of 34 results.
Tampa2,
It looks like the pricing for the Komastu was left off & the $29K is for a TCM FTB16K-7, Komatsu 3 Wheeler have a Model # like FB15, 18, 20M-4. Secondly, the Crown appears to be a basic 3000 lb. model vs the other makes that quoted 3500 lb. units.
But I agree, after some one has made a decision the ball game is over, no need to imply or say out right someone made a wrong buy or didn't do their job properly - that is less than professional & it wouldn't change the final score - Toyota +1; the rest of the pack 0.
  • Posted 22 Mar 2013 11:04
  • Modified 22 Mar 2013 11:05 by poster
  • Reply by johnr_j
  • Georgia, United States
"Have An Exceptional Day!"
CROWN
  • Posted 21 Mar 2013 19:13
  • Reply by Kevin_ZHU
  • Guangdong, China
No pain, no gain.
What I'm more interested in hearing about is whether or you think that's fairly common pricing - particularly the Komatsu? Seems kind of high, no?
  • Posted 14 Mar 2013 21:47
  • Reply by AutoEV
  • Florida, United States
After having read this these responses, there is one thing I know for sure... "Natan" will probably get his advice elsewhere in the future. Lay off the guy, he just wanted a little product advice, not a lecture.
  • Posted 14 Mar 2013 21:45
  • Reply by AutoEV
  • Florida, United States
Automate&Elevate
I thought that Natan said they already purchased a truck.
I wouldn't rank Komatsu as a leading manufacturer of electric forklift trucks. In all my years in this industry I have only ever seen one Komatsu electric.
  • Posted 13 Mar 2013 21:41
  • Reply by duodeluxe
  • United States
duodeluxe
I would recommend the Komatsu model. Although the most expensive, it would be of greater use to you, as it is a faster forklift truck, with a faster lift speed. But then it all depends on your requirements.
  • Posted 12 Mar 2013 20:58
  • Reply by ray_d
  • Staffordshire, United Kingdom
http://www.hflifttrucks.co.uk
shhhh....
let them find out on their own...
  • Posted 9 Mar 2013 09:30
  • Modified 9 Mar 2013 09:30 by poster
  • Reply by edward_t
  • South Carolina, United States
"it's not rocket surgery"
Just wait til I tell the guys at work tomorrow the 49ers lost.
  • Posted 8 Mar 2013 15:11
  • Reply by L1ftmech
  • Tennessee, United States
Some of the info may have been to late for this purchaser but someone else may see it and use it to be better informed. 49ers lost because they scored less points/allowed more points, they were behind when the clock ran out.
  • Posted 8 Mar 2013 12:21
  • Reply by meliftman
  • Alabama, United States
Liftman
Retired
Elberta, Al.
Looks to me like the ball game was over when the boss bought the Toyota and the rest of this thread sounds a lot like second guessing why the 49ers lost the Super Bowl or trying to sell flood/hurricane insurance after Sandy hit the NE.
  • Posted 3 Mar 2013 21:17
  • Reply by johnr_j
  • Georgia, United States
"Have An Exceptional Day!"
and yes NISSAN is a good electric 3/4 wheel truck and you dont need any special laptops and cables to do most repairs can access everything thru the dash panel with the password to diagnoze and configure everything(good choice is the 1N1 Model)
  • Posted 3 Mar 2013 17:00
  • Reply by kevin_t
  • Pennsylvania, United States
One thing you ALSO want to consider in your decision is the cost of ownership....how much are the parts to repair it when needed going to cost and if your going to have quick access to those parts when needed.
Also if your going to rely on the dealer for the repairs what is the labor rate going to be and how reliable is the dealer,are they going to be there soon or "when they get to it"?
some dealerships will practically give a truck away just to get your business then make it up in parts and labor later on down the road.
Also another thing is how easy is the truck to repair if your doing the repairs yourself,are you going to be even able to do the repairs yourself or is it going to be that your going to need the dealer to work on it because they have the proprietary laptop and cables or other diagnostic equipment not availabke to the common man
  • Posted 3 Mar 2013 16:54
  • Reply by kevin_t
  • Pennsylvania, United States
Research in your case didn't mean much I see. Guess this so called expert worked for the Toyota Dealer. On an after thought, why didn't you look at Nissan? They make a very good reliable three wheel electric truck. I would say, the best on the market.
JMO.
  • Posted 3 Mar 2013 13:07
  • Reply by meliftman
  • Alabama, United States
Liftman
Retired
Elberta, Al.
Natan just a guy was taling rubbish yes the Doosan is a cheap pile of crap ive worked on them and know how bad they are, TCM never had a good reputation over this side of the pond you dont hear of them anymore Crown really are a good piece of kit these days the SC will stand up to just about anything out there and in my eyes is a better machine that the toyota and if infolink is fitted is head and shoulders above it.
  • Posted 1 Mar 2013 10:56
  • Reply by lifter01
  • West Yorkshire, United Kingdom
I actually evaluated some more including the Linde and some others. Some were good but did not fit our needs for some reason or another. I agree that 2 of the 3 are not considered good, and that is why I did not go for it. I did investigate all the major brands, except for Toyota. I thought Raymond was Toyota, but they seem to have 2 companies.
I disagree with you that Crown is a cheap brand. Crown is considered a top brand, and is made in America. I think I made a good choice and it was actually a more expensive option.
  • Posted 1 Mar 2013 05:38
  • Reply by Natan
  • New Jersey, United States

Post your Reply

Forkliftaction.com accepts no responsibility for forum content and requires forum participants to adhere to the rules. Click here for more information.

Having trouble using the Discussion Forums? Contact us for help.

Movers & Shakers
Jospeh E Creed Jospeh E Creed
CEO, Caterpillar Inc
Secretary general, European Rental Association
Chairman of the Board of Directors, UgoWork
vice president, Investor Relations, Konecranes
Movers & Shakers
Jospeh E Creed Jospeh E Creed
CEO, Caterpillar Inc
Secretary general, European Rental Association
Chairman of the Board of Directors, UgoWork
vice president, Investor Relations, Konecranes