Discussion:
Service estimates

Due to the economy a lot of customers are now requesting quotes (we call them estimates) on repairs prior to giving the approval on road service work. Some of the repairs might be as small as replacing a master cylinder. Back in the day most of these jobs were service calls that were phoned in. So now we have to jump through a bunch of hoops to basically do a road service call.
My question is what is the norm? If the jobs comes in under the estimate do you bill them the estimated price? If so, how do you justify billing 4 hours when it only took 2 1/2 hours?
If you think that the customer should be billed the actual time and materials and it is under the estimate then please explain.
I can see both sides but a big part of me says when you get a price on painting your house for $4000, that is what you get billed and there is no breakdown of labor or gallons of paint used on the job.
  • Posted 17 Jun 2011 03:45
  • By duodeluxe
  • joined 11 Feb'05 - 923 messages
  • United States
duodeluxe
Showing items 1 - 7 of 7 results.
This is a great subject and already I see lots of great answers. Personally, I quote at night- it is SO time consuming. I also call it a Repair Estimate these days which gives me the ability to ask for more if I hit problems. I use my iPhone if I have additional repairs I run into and snap/ send a picture to the decision maker as the job is taking place.
My repair estimates read: Parts and labor to....
That way, in the unlikely event I am able to beat my own optimistic quote the extra is mine :). Customer doesn't know how much is parts, how much is labor. Years ago on my road trip reports I would provide time on, arrival time, leave time and time off. Huge mistake and unnecessary. My experience is the customer is much more concerned about a QUALITY job at a perceived fair price. If you hit a snag, get your decision maker in the loop as soon as possible. His biggest concern is keeping his boss happy and that means he can explain what happened because he knows what happened.
  • Posted 30 Jun 2011 21:29
  • By Forkliftt
  • joined 13 Jul'09 - 321 messages
  • Louisiana, United States
Steve
steve at forkliftt dot com
That's how I feel. There is more work involved preparing an "estimate" than just taking a service call over the phone.
Look at the automotive industry, I think that they average person knows that they are being charged flat rate where a technician spends 2 hours repairing a car and they get charged for 5 hours. The big difference is that the customer can't see that only 2 hours was spent on his car.

Another thing I find odd is that on all shop jobs, no matter what they come in for, we charge each customer about 1.5 hours to do a thorough check out of the forklift truck. Then an estimate is prepared which could take another 1.5 hours in looking up the parts etc. and although the people involved in preparing the estimate probably make more than the technician who checked out the truck that work is at no charge.
  • Posted 24 Jun 2011 21:31
  • By duodeluxe
  • joined 11 Feb'05 - 923 messages
  • United States
duodeluxe
i always tried to talk them out of a quote by letting them know that if it's quoted that's the price. if we come in under on the labor good for us if we come in over good for you and because of that we're going to quote higher than what it might take on average to do the job to cover minor deviations like "stripped bolts" (or more likely lost bolt or that wire terminal you broke). bottom line, you want a quote you are probably gonna pay more than with no quote. i always found that if you tell it like it is up front there are no hard feelings after.
  • Posted 24 Jun 2011 10:27
  • By toyzilla
  • joined 29 Mar'10 - 175 messages
  • Texas, United States
easier to ask forgiveness than to ask permission.
i all ways put this is a close estimate and does not include any unforeseen worn items you never know what will come up and who else has been wrenching on it
  • Posted 24 Jun 2011 05:43
  • By TIMBO
  • joined 7 Jun'11 - 19 messages
  • Georgia, United States
I estimate time and materials, then quote "up to" 110% of that. Then I bill for what time I actually spend on the job.

Usually it's just what I expected, but sometimes the extra 10% gets eaten up by rusty parts that refuse to come apart or damage that I just couldn't see until everything was taken apart.

If everything goes wrong and I can see that it's going to be way over estimate, I stop work and explain the situation to the customer. Usually they give the go ahead to continue the work.

Mostly though, the job comes in under estimate and everyone's happy.
  • Posted 17 Jun 2011 12:10
  • By lumberjack
  • joined 27 Jul'07 - 181 messages
  • Maryland, United States
I find that there are just few customers that want a estimate before doing any kind of work. The other ones, that have an expensive repair, I let them know about what the cost will be. Very rarely does it come in under the estimate and if it goes over I usually eat some of the extra time. If it takes less hours, then just "hang out" and tinker with other things on the lift. I wouldn't leave and charge them more hours than you were actually there. A couple places I go makes visitors sign in and out. Customer may not have a clue what you are doing but they sure can figure out labor hours. Then there are the other type of customer that completely trusts you and doesn't pay attention to anything, including the invoices. "Just make my forklifts work so we can run this operation smoothly, we have other things to worry about" I'm very careful not to do anything to screw up that relationship.
  • Posted 17 Jun 2011 11:27
  • By mrfixit
  • joined 11 Dec'08 - 1,434 messages
  • New York, United States
When working road service I always broke my estimates down by parts and labor, not including sales tax or shipping cost and I let my customers know this. I always gave myself a little lee way on labor time just in case I ran into those irritating things like stripped screws, etc., If everything went right with no gremlins popping up then I would come in under the estimate. When it was time for the customer to sign my ticket I made a point of highlighting the labor and letting him/her know that I came in under the estimated cost of repair. They were usually very appreciative and I got repeat calls from them. As a matter of fact, quite a few (including the one I work for now) did away with the need for estimates altogether after awhile and just gave me a max/repair and no need for approval under the max. If you said it was going to take you from 8am-12pm to do the repair but left at 10:30am but still billed them for the full estimate until 12pm, aren't you setting yourself up for a possible lawsuit?
  • Posted 17 Jun 2011 04:58
  • By joe_d
  • joined 25 May'10 - 253 messages
  • Texas, United States
Ain't nothing I can't fix but a broken heart and the break of day!

Post your Reply

Forkliftaction accepts no responsibility for forum content and requires forum participants to adhere to our rules of conduct. Click here for more information.

If you are having trouble using the Discussion Forums, please contact us for help.

Forkliftaction turns 25 Brisbane, QLD, Australia
Upcoming industry events …
September 23-25, 2025 - SÃO PAULO, Brazil
October 15-16, 2025 - Las Vegas, United States
November 25-26, 2025 - Singapore, Singapore
Global Industry News
edition #1238 - 10 July 2025
This week Forkliftaction News is celebrating its 25th anniversary! A wonderful achievement given we launched at a time when just 6% of the world’s population were internet users, according to Internet World Stats . Over the coming weeks, we will be sharing stories about our history and rolling out more celebrations, so keep an eye out... Continue reading
Movers & Shakers
Laura Ness Owens Laura Ness Owens
Chief marketing officer, Bobcat Company
Chief commercial officer, Teradyne Robotics
CEO, MHEDA
President, European Rental Association (ERA)
Global Industry News
edition #1238 - 10 July 2025
This week Forkliftaction News is celebrating its 25th anniversary! A wonderful achievement given we launched at a time when just 6% of the world’s population were internet users, according to Internet World Stats . Over the coming weeks, we will be sharing stories about our history and rolling out more celebrations, so keep an eye out... Continue reading

Showcased in the Virtual Expo

Movers & Shakers
Laura Ness Owens Laura Ness Owens
Chief marketing officer, Bobcat Company
Chief commercial officer, Teradyne Robotics
CEO, MHEDA
President, European Rental Association (ERA)
Upcoming industry events …
September 23-25, 2025 - SÃO PAULO, Brazil
October 15-16, 2025 - Las Vegas, United States
November 25-26, 2025 - Singapore, Singapore
Global Industry News
edition #1238 - 10 July 2025
This week Forkliftaction News is celebrating its 25th anniversary! A wonderful achievement given we launched at a time when just 6% of the world’s population were internet users, according to Internet World Stats . Over the coming weeks, we will be sharing stories about our history and rolling out more celebrations, so keep an eye out... Continue reading
Fact of the week
The dot-com bubble, a period of large and rapid investments in internet-based companies, peaked in 2000 and saw the Nasdaq Composite index rise by 579%. Then the bubble imploded. As the value of tech stocks plummeted, cash-strapped internet start-ups became worthless and collapsed.