Discussion:
Reach truck with racking v Bendi truck narrow aisle

Hello!

We are looking at installing racking in our storage unit. We have two options,

- to buy a reach truck (less pallet spaces, but cheaper set up)
or - buy a narrow aisle forklift (more pallet spaces but quite a bit more expensive to set up

Obviously with a reach truck we would need to have a counterbalance for loading/unloading vehicals?

Is narrow aisle the future or is it personal preference? I could imagine the process of using a bendi being a lot slower than a reach truck? Do the narrow aisle fork lifts take a long time to get used to?

Thanks very much!!!

Jon
  • Posted 10 May 2009 00:21
  • Discussion started by Jonathan
  • Cheshire, United Kingdom
Showing items 31 - 37 of 37 results.
from my experience you Reach truck are cheaper to operator
  • Posted 15 May 2009 12:59
  • Reply by beast411
  • Minnesota, United States
Jonaton,

Just for clarification when you speak of a reach truck are you talking about a:

Mast reach unit - more common in the European & Asian markets? or a

Carriage Pantograph reach unit - most common in North America?
  • Posted 14 May 2009 22:08
  • Reply by johnr_j
  • Georgia, United States
"Have An Exceptional Day!"
A Bendi can be used to load and unload trucks.
Whether a Bendi is faster or slower than a reach at placing and removing loads from racks is highly dependent on the aisle width. If you go with the absolute minimum aisle width (I don't recommend this), it is going to slow you down quite a bit (this applies to both reaches and Bendis). The wider you go, the faster you go.
You also have Swing Masts and Turrets. Both of which can actually provide faster putaways and extractions than a Bendi or a Reach, and in narrower aisles (Swing Masts need a wider aisle than turrets, but still narrower than a bendi). Turrets generally can't be used to load and unload trucks, Swing Masts can but do not work as well as a Bendi or standard forklift. Turrets generally require guidance systems.
  • Posted 14 May 2009 01:44
  • Reply by InventoryOps
  • Wisconsin, United States
I would say the real questions come in what the whole operation is doing. a pallett jack and reach truck may be the way to unload single stacked loads from a truck and put them on shelves, -if- all loads are single stacked, and have to be inspected as soon as they are off the truck. on the other hand, if the loads are stacked, but do not have to be scanned and inspected by someone walking around the load, the bendi-flexi style of articulating truck may be better. the real difference is in does someone have to get off (and back on) the sit down unit with every pallet load.
  • Posted 10 May 2009 23:10
  • Modified 10 May 2009 23:11 by poster
  • Reply by edward_t
  • South Carolina, United States
i would say the reach truck....the bendi is handier for unloading lorries ,,,reach trucks are for indoor use only ,,reps might tell u different.....
  • Posted 10 May 2009 19:31
  • Reply by DAMO
  • DUBLIN, Ireland
would you say the bendi/flexi is easier to drive than the reach truck? I thought the narrow aisle would be harder as there is a lot less room to maneuver...It seems a lot of people are heading down the narrow aisle route...

Are the bendi trucks easy to load/unload lorries?

Thanks again
Jon
  • Posted 10 May 2009 02:40
  • Reply by Jonathan
  • Cheshire, United Kingdom
Hi jonathan i would go narrow aisle easier to drive less breakages more space ,,,,,,chosing the right one is the key.regards damo
  • Posted 10 May 2009 01:04
  • Reply by DAMO
  • DUBLIN, Ireland

Post your Reply

Forkliftaction.com accepts no responsibility for forum content and requires forum participants to adhere to the rules. Click here for more information.

Having trouble using the Discussion Forums? Contact us for help.

Upcoming industry events …
May 09-11, 2025 - Bangalore, India
October 21-23, 2025 - Panama City, Panama
July 15-17, 2025 - Hong Kong, Hong Kong
Global Industry News
edition #1228 - 1 May 2025
There is simply no ignoring the push for a greener, more sustainable materials handling equipment industry as manufacturers and customers alike seek eco-friendly solutions to reduce or eliminate carbon emissions... Continue reading
Global Industry News
edition #1228 - 1 May 2025
There is simply no ignoring the push for a greener, more sustainable materials handling equipment industry as manufacturers and customers alike seek eco-friendly solutions to reduce or eliminate carbon emissions... Continue reading
Movers & Shakers
Linda Häkkilä Linda Häkkilä
vice president, Investor Relations, Konecranes
vice president operations, Elokon Group
President, EP Equipment Europe
Senior vice president human resources, Kalmar