We bought a used S120XLS about 3 years ago. It worked great, but we found that it continued to have an oil leak. A couple lift repair shops in town each took a crack at fixing it, but always failed. Our current provider indicated they knew what needed to be done.
They replaced the Trans input seal, the rear main seal, and oil pan gasket... and yep it still leaked. At which point they found a crack in the bell housing. So we had that replaced. They also replaced the timing cover and gasket and replaced the valve cover gasket. The leak is now fixed. However, now we hear a ticking noise, the lift has lost all power and barely runs. The shop took it back again to evaluate and now has presented us with a quote for a new engine. They are claiming that based on the age, (1999) the unit needs a new timing belt, the cams are worn and valves can't be adjusted any further and they hear the knock but are unable to pinpoint it - possibly #3 cylinder. They are saying based on the hours (9,731) and age - they want to replace the engine for $11,000.
From my teams perspective the engine ran fine when we started looking for the leak. And now after all this work, the unit is completely useless. I realize that the failure could be coincidental, but I don't know enough about engines to call bull $hit on this.
For those of you who are more familiar with this engine and unit, can you see a correlation between the two that we could investigate?
Do I accept the bad luck and drop another 11K into this unit or do I bail on the whole thing, sell it for parts and find something else?
I appreciate your thoughts on this.
Showing items 1 - 3 of 3 results.
My recommendation would be to buy your next truck from a actual dealer instead of rolling the dice. Don't get me wrong there are some good non OEM affiliated used truck dealers out there but few and far between. Most OEM dealers are not going to sell you something this is junk.
One other way to go about it is to ask who ever you are buying it from to loan it to your or even rent it to you for a short period of time and then have someone come in and take a look at it to make sure you are not getting junk.
Actually just got off the phone with the local Hyster dealer.
He echoed your sentiment about putting that kind of money into it.
I will likely have them take a look and then evaluate the situation. But I'm leaning towards scrapping it and getting something newer. I can't justify a new unit based on the volume of work we do with it. So once again I will be rolling the dice on a used piece of equipment....
I think it will all come down to how much you trust the current shop and what they are telling you. It is not uncommon, especially after having a couple of shops work on it, to see other issues show up.
The other issue is doing a Google search similar trucks are being listed anywhere from $6500.00 to $12,000.00 so do you really want to invest another $11,000.00 into it?
Assuming that you have only had this one company look at the engine noise before dropping or scrapping the truck I would bring in at least 1 other company to look at it maybe going as far as asking your local Hyster dealer.
Forkliftaction accepts no responsibility for forum content and requires forum participants to adhere to our rules of conduct. Click here for more information.
If you are having trouble using the Discussion Forums, please contact us for help.