Discussion:
Help in deciding what forklift to purchase

This may be my second post - couldn't find the first one.

We currently own a Tusk 2008 LP Model 500 CG-16 which has been wonderful for us. However, we are purchasing a horizontal baler along with moving to a new facility and need to switch from LP to Electric. Here are my questions:

1) What brands are better - we have received quotes on a Yale, CAT, Nissan, Clark and Mitsubishi.?
2) Are any of these types better in getting parts for them..service as well as pricing?
3) Would we need a side shift hydraulic option to use clamps in order to pick up our bales?
4) Is there any special wiring that we would need to plug the electric machine up with?
5) Is a 36V battery powered forklift the same power as our LP forklift?
6) Are there good clamps that have a quick dis-connect so we don't have to have mechanics here to switch from clamps to forks?

Look forward to hearing any suggetions or comments you have.
Thank you,
Barb
  • Posted 9 Jul 2011 02:25
  • By barb_b
  • joined 8 Jul'11 - 3 messages
  • Virginia, United States
If it ain't broke, experiment.
Showing items 1 - 7 of 7 results.
Hello! I am only going to mirror the other comments that have been made and say that everyone has their brand that they prefer the most. I have discovered that they all have pros and cons. I would advise you to test them out and see what you think.
  • Posted 23 Aug 2011 06:28
  • By ForkLifted
  • joined 23 Aug'11 - 7 messages
  • Utah, United States
We are an non-profit after market recycling company and we bale textiles, cardboard, ect. I am very pleased with all the great information everyone has given me.
I believe I have enough to make a decision on.
Thanks again everyone!
  • Posted 12 Jul 2011 09:57
  • By barb_b
  • joined 8 Jul'11 - 3 messages
  • Virginia, United States
If it ain't broke, experiment.
Barb;
What Industrial application are you intentions of use for the forktruck you are seeking? Is it going to be used in the waste recycling industry? If it is I would highly recommend that you spec out the requirements you need and are looking for. Make it a sound and binding contracting agreement. Stipulate that if your unit is down due lack of part or labor availability for longer then a predetermined time that your firm is not put out of business. Most new equipment dealer do not like to stock dollar bills on a shelve to collect dust for parts they may not use but only on rare instances. Keep in mind like Ed said in his blog there are many brands available and only you can decide what is the best for your industrial application. If you are in the waste recylce industry may I suggest that you may find petinent information in a waste recycler's trade journal. John also has given you some excellent advise, batteries for industrial forklifts are the single most expensive part to a unit. Anything you do up front to preserve the battery's life will end up a plus. The lead time to replace one will be your firms worst enemy even though most battery failures can be repaired but not all.
  • Posted 12 Jul 2011 06:18
  • By MEngr
  • joined 15 Jan'11 - 247 messages
  • Missouri, United States
Barb
Do yourself a favor buy a single point watering system with for your battery with a visual indicator (little white dot) that alerts personnel the battery needs water. The few extra bucks will save you money & extend the life of the battery by refilling the battery cells to the proper level. Improper watering of a battery has shorten the life of batteries more than any other cause.

Go with a 48volt system - as Ed pointed out the truck will have faster travel speeds as well as lifting/clamping/tilt speeds. And the last time I checked there is very little difference in price by going to 48v - like less than $100. Plus your lifts motors/electrical/electronic components will see less less current draw (less heat) & live longer save you money in the long run.
  • Posted 10 Jul 2011 17:57
  • By johnr_j
  • joined 3 Jun'06 - 1,446 messages
  • Georgia, United States
"Have An Exceptional Day!"
Thank you Ed -
I appreciate your feedback, it greatly helped direct me in a better direction.
  • Posted 10 Jul 2011 00:53
  • By barb_b
  • joined 8 Jul'11 - 3 messages
  • Virginia, United States
If it ain't broke, experiment.
1) What brands are better - we have received quotes on a Yale, CAT, Nissan, Clark and Mitsubishi.?

almost everyone on here will push the brand they work for, or what they know most about, as this is natural to consider the brands we know about to be "best". "Best" actually has different meanings in different applications. are you considering only brand new?
if you decide on a used electric, I would plan on purchasing a new and very good quality battery, as the battery will be a very large portion of the value of the truck, and the better the battery (and how well it is matched to the truck and charger, and maintained), the happier you will be with what ever brand forklift you purchase.

2) Are any of these types better in getting parts for them..service as well as pricing?

about the same, pretty much

3) Would we need a side shift hydraulic option to use clamps in order to pick up our bales?
I would think you would want a 4 spool hydraulic option, and the better quality side shift option (not all side shifts can handle a clamp's side force). I would also think you would want the "chopper controlled hydraulic motor speed control option"

4) Is there any special wiring that we would need to plug the electric machine up with?
there is a charger that will need considerable AC power, some are 3 phase 480 volts, 30 Amp lines, the charger plugs into the battery on the electric forklift, and has a connector that matches the truck and battery

5) Is a 36V battery powered forklift the same power as our LP forklift?
roughly the same, the LPG may be geared for a higher top speed, and I would recommend you go with 48 volt battery (over 36volt) for top drive speed.

6) Are there good clamps that have a quick dis-connect so we don't have to have mechanics here to switch from clamps to forks?
yes, this is actually pretty common.
  • Posted 9 Jul 2011 10:07
  • Modified 9 Jul 2011 22:48 by poster
  • By edward_t
  • joined 5 Mar'08 - 2,334 messages
  • South Carolina, United States
"it's not rocket surgery"
Contact your local Linde Dealer and ask about the RX60 Series (80 Volt).
  • Posted 9 Jul 2011 03:13
  • By EasyM
  • joined 14 May'05 - 101 messages
  • South Carolina, United States

Post your Reply

Forkliftaction accepts no responsibility for forum content and requires forum participants to adhere to our rules of conduct. Click here for more information.

If you are having trouble using the Discussion Forums, please contact us for help.

Fact of the week
The word "robotics" was coined by Russian-born American science-fiction writer Isaac Asimov who first used the word in 1942 in his short story 'Runabout'. He characterised robots as helpful servants and as "a better, cleaner race."
Fact of the week
The word "robotics" was coined by Russian-born American science-fiction writer Isaac Asimov who first used the word in 1942 in his short story 'Runabout'. He characterised robots as helpful servants and as "a better, cleaner race."