Report this forum post

I second Tennessee's notion. I just reviewed the LD Bailey 'white paper', and whether it was or not, it definitely read like it was written as an intentional advocacy for IC truck suppliers.

While there are several questionable points of data (maintenance costs, battery washer costs, etc, battery life cycle), the most inaccurate cost I saw was, indeed, the per hour kWh cost of the battery driven truck (I will give them a pass on the LPG tank costs, assuming a bit of a dated evaluation).

LD Bailey correctly indicated that they measured consumption from a less efficient system, versus that which is on the market today, but to claim (if I understand that claim correctly), that an electric truck uses over 23 kWh per hour is not accurate (for example, I would like to see what else is going on during the high peak times, for example). A typical 5k capacity electric forklift battery may have approximately a 40 kWh capacity. At full discharge, one must return 32 kWh back to that battery, given a 'full discharge' being equivalent to an 80% discharge (80% - or 32 kWh). Assuming from the study 6 hours of use per cycle, that would mean that it takes 141 kWh of electricity to return 32 kWh back to the battery, or something like a 23% level of efficiency (almost 80% of the input electricity is lost during the charge. Even in the least efficient charging systems from days past, that is way off base.

Don't get me wrong, I have seen several 'studies' that just give an equivalent transfer charging cost equation (if I need to return 32 kWh to my battery, it must cost 32 kWh to do so, or at 8.8 cents per kWh, or about $2.82). That is definitely not a fair assessment, either. There are going to be losses during a charge, even with the most efficient systems. However, the efficiency will still be over 50%.

Anyway, that's enough on that from me.
  • Posted 3 Oct 2008 10:48
  • By pbace
  • joined 15 Feb'08 - 8 messages
  • Virginia, United States

This is ONLY to be used to report flooding, spam, advertising and problematic (harassing, abusive or crude) posts.

Indicates mandatory field
Upcoming industry events …
October 6-9, 2025 - Detroit, MI, United States
October 6-9, 2025 - Detroit, MI, United States
November 14, 2025 - Melbourne, Australia
Global Industry News
edition #1237 - 3 July 2025
While innovation and new technology are evolving at what seems to be an ever-increasing pace, the need to capture the data (telemetry) from this tech, and the ability to utilise it (telematics) for efficiency and cost savings, is one area attracting more and more attention ... Continue reading
Movers & Shakers
Jeannette Walker Jeannette Walker
CEO, MHEDA
President, European Rental Association (ERA)
Chief marketing officer, JLT Mobile Computers
Chief executive officer, East Penn Manufacturing
Upcoming industry events …
October 6-9, 2025 - Detroit, MI, United States
October 6-9, 2025 - Detroit, MI, United States
November 14, 2025 - Melbourne, Australia
Fact of the week
The use of "hello" as a telephone greeting is attributed to Thomas Edison. He is said to have suggested it as a simpler alternative to other greetings, such as "Do I get you?" or "Are you there?".
Global Industry News
edition #1237 - 3 July 2025
While innovation and new technology are evolving at what seems to be an ever-increasing pace, the need to capture the data (telemetry) from this tech, and the ability to utilise it (telematics) for efficiency and cost savings, is one area attracting more and more attention ... Continue reading
Movers & Shakers
Jeannette Walker Jeannette Walker
CEO, MHEDA
President, European Rental Association (ERA)
Chief marketing officer, JLT Mobile Computers
Chief executive officer, East Penn Manufacturing