Report this forum post

Having worked for one of the developers supplying FC power units for fork trucks I can say that large customers in NA operating on 2-3 shifts per day are moving to hydrogen over battery trucks due to increased productivity. Furthermore, they will convert their entire fleet, even class 3s, to FC so they can totally eliminate battery charging infrastructure. A large distribution centre with FC fleet will move more goods for less money than the same centre running battery trucks. In the end this is the only metric that counts for them.

For these customers, lithium does not add anything significant over LA batteries as they have higher upfront costs and still require charging (i.e. downtime). Fast charging sounds good in theory but, as someone pointed out the power required to charge in 5 min is massive and with a fleet of 200 trucks is completely unworkable not to mention the electrical peak demand charges.

Battery electric will still have their place and will continue to be used on smaller fleets or 1 shift operations; a significant part of the overall market. They will also continue to be used in Europe as the large, multi shift distribution centres are less common and hydrogen is more expensive due to lack of Liquid H2 infrastructure (thanks NASA!).
  • Posted 13 Oct 2017 16:03
  • By toller
  • joined 18 Feb'11 - 11 messages
  • British Columbia, Canada

This is ONLY to be used to report flooding, spam, advertising and problematic (harassing, abusive or crude) posts.

Indicates mandatory field
Upcoming industry events …
January 28-30, 2026 - Bangkok, Thailand
March 4-5, 2026 - Detroit, Michigan, United States
March 24-26, 2026 - Stuttgart, Germany
Latest job alerts …
Erie, PA, United States
Dayton, OH, United States
Editorial calendar - planned features
CONSTRUCTION FORKLIFTS
HANDLING GOODS IN THE COLD
LOADING/UNLOADING FREIGHT
BROWNFIELD AUTOMATION
FORKLIFT ATTACHMENTS
BATTERY AFFORDABILITY AND LIFETIME
FORKLIFT SAFETY
Upcoming industry events …
January 28-30, 2026 - Bangkok, Thailand
March 4-5, 2026 - Detroit, Michigan, United States
March 24-26, 2026 - Stuttgart, Germany
Fact of the week
Foundling hatches are safe, anonymous drop-off points for unwanted infants, allowing parents in crisis a way to surrender a baby safely without fear of punishment, ensuring the child is rescued and cared for. The concept started in the 12th century, was abandoned in the late 19th century, then reintroduced in 1952. It has since been adopted in many countries.
Toplift Ferrari TFC36-48
Stoney Creek, Ontario, Canada
Used - Sale
USD1
Manitou MH25-4
Braeside, Melbourne, Victoria, Australia
Hire
Movers & Shakers
Jett Chitanand Jett Chitanand
President EPG Americas, Ehrhardt Partner Group (EPG)
CEO, Duravant
Manager of automated solutions engineering and implementation, MHS Lift
President and CEO, Manitou Group