Discussion:
Carolina Handling or Crown

I am trying to decide which vendor I should use for service and new equipment down the road. What exprience have you guys had with these two in Atlanta or in the southeast?
  • Posted 8 Oct 2010 00:35
  • Discussion started by atllift
  • Georgia, United States
Showing items 61 - 75 of 79 results.
Let see Yale used to sell MBP to Kroger but now it is what band? Large Nationa Accounts aren't stupid - if the truck don't work out and the cost to operate them & down time are excessive, service is non responsive to their needs (in teh customers viewpoint) - then they change. Look at Home Depot, Wal-Mart (here I'm referring to ICE units) they have changed. Lowes is a along time National Account 4 Yale right now - some day they could change - if someone wanted to buy into the account.

Coke Cola (CCE) used to be a Yale that changed for some reason, eh.
Every brand of forklift can point to an account/model that ran many hours past the "norm". I worked for Mitsubishi at a point in time a nation wide trucking company out of Ohio that had hundreds in there fleet found the engines to run over 20,000 in there break bult terminal that run 7/24/365 & the cross hatch on the engine cylinder walls was still visible. Then they went to the 4G63/64 engine - the romance ended & opened teh door to a competitor.
Certainly you would find it difficult to find parts for a 66 year old truck - my doctor is have a hard time to find OEM parts for my 1944 knee - so its a plastic one.
Yale & Hyste have & had extensive National / Major Accounts staff for many years (Hyster & Clark used to have the best NA programs going), right? Or they did then along came 2007. The year I hung up my lift spurs.
Have a great day.
  • Posted 14 Oct 2010 02:55
  • Reply by johnr_j
  • Georgia, United States
Once again red and gray talk about yesterday.Whenever we see their sales people in the field they compare their today product with our yesterday product.I worked in the field years ago at an account where the red guys came in and compaired their newest stand up with a proud 10 year old Hyster with 60,ooo hours on it.Never brought up our modern product.Funny thing why.The funny thing was.... They were promising a NEW A.C. product to be out soon.The Hyster A.C. stand up was already out there working.They couldn't compete with today.Now they have an A.C.
The next thing I observed with red and gray is that they come into an account with low , low, machine prices and parts prices.Amazing how temporary those prices are.They have a way of sneaking up over time.
The Naaco twins have lots of room to grow in market share.With their superior product I am sure they will.No one offers more equipment variety than Hyster.Red and gray are ONLY warehouse.They like to lock in a national account with charts and graphs.Then "OOOHHH look at me, I've got market share"."I must be the best".
I watched a team of slick talking saleman talk a group of executives at a factory into buying two of their trucks to replace one Hyster.They did not offer a truck the size of a Hyster 50,000 pound truck.They had charts and graphs that they said PROVED they could do twice the work in the same amount of time.This would save money! ooohhh aHHHH !
I personally had the delighted pleasure to watch that ten year old Hyster 500 rumble into the building and get down to business while those two (replacement trucks) sat in the shop with busted transmissions and torque converters.The newbies were never able to do the job.Years later.The Hyster is still carrying on business.Carrying twice the load hour after hour.Day after day.Quality gentlemen.The intruders are gone.
I've got a 1944 Hyster out back right now that could be put to work this afternoon if need be.
You see I can talk about yesterday too.If my competition wants to.Charts and graphs, Bahh ! Lets talk about work.
  • Posted 13 Oct 2010 23:16
  • Reply by Madman
  • North Carolina, United States
Just for the record when it comes to narrow aisle, class II products both Raymond & Crown have the market wrapped up 60% +. Yale has been in the market a long time & Hyster first got into class II when they bought Lewis Sheppard. Neither the Nacco twins market share added together come close to either Raymond or Crown individually. Greater market share translates to greater customer acceptance. Customer make teh lift truck world go around - buy trucks, pay for service, buy parts In Class III ,Yale many, many moons ago had the lions share but Crown leap frogged them in a big way with better product & quality & not by low $$ (like MPB or what ver Hyster calls it)).
  • Posted 13 Oct 2010 09:37
  • Reply by johnr_j
  • Georgia, United States
Hey Madman. Being a former Certified Raymond tech, I can honestly say that we had to be re-certifed by factory exam every 3 years after passing the level II test. As for can bus communication, Raymond has been using it for years. Now instead of power card, sytem card, vfc card, carriage control card, etc., you only have a couple of power amps and a vehicle manager (and carriage control card on OPs). I took care of a very large customer (approx. 200 pcs. of equipment) for many years. They were a diverse mixture of brands but I still found the Raymond (and Mitsi/Raymonds) easier to repair and more dependable. Where I work now we have a fleet of 98 with 55 of them Raymonds. As long as the maintenance (my job) is kept up, the only breakdowns I see is due to age and operator error.
  • Posted 13 Oct 2010 04:42
  • Reply by joe_d
  • Texas, United States
Ain't nothing I can't fix but a broken heart and the break of day!
The Hyster narrow aisle and walkie rider is the most dependable warehouse product out there right now.They are not getting the attention they should because red and gray have been getting all the attention.The AC motors are rock solid.The can bus communication system left the world of large harnesses all over the truck behind years ago.Unlike Hyster, Crown and Raymond continued to spread electronic components all over their machines. Hyster (made in North Carolina by the way) started pulling ahead in warehouse technology about 5 years ago.Smooth controls and dependability to boot.Hyster also demands that all technicians ,even veterans,continue their factory training.Red and Gray hope to keep them at bay.
  • Posted 13 Oct 2010 04:10
  • Reply by Madman
  • North Carolina, United States
never worried about the kids, its the Xs that I worried about. they always wanted more than teh contract agreed to - kinda like some lift truck dealers don't you know.
  • Posted 12 Oct 2010 07:26
  • Reply by johnr_j
  • Georgia, United States
I heard that your kids almost always caught up to you...

;-)
  • Posted 12 Oct 2010 02:22
  • Modified 12 Oct 2010 02:22 by poster
  • Reply by edward_t
  • South Carolina, United States
"it's not rocket surgery"
that saying works too - just never heard it in my neighborhoods being nomadic I moved quite a bit.
  • Posted 12 Oct 2010 01:51
  • Reply by johnr_j
  • Georgia, United States
And all this time I thought the saying was really that people in grass houses should not store thrones, as a result of the guy who collected toilettes having his ceiling crush in on his sod house.
:-)

Isn't "f.u.d.*" such an interesting (yet unscrupulous and difficult to combat) sales tactic?
*= Fear, Uncertainty, & Doubt

I would also like to note that the more experienced people around here might notice that while we all know plenty of things "less than perfect" with many forklift designs, we rarely notice what is good, since we don't have to fix the good parts. kind of like asking us what is a good forklift, since no one ever calls and says "come over for a service call, I Have a really -good- forklift for you to look at", all we get is; "this piece of stuff...."
  • Posted 11 Oct 2010 22:41
  • Modified 12 Oct 2010 01:45 by poster
  • Reply by edward_t
  • South Carolina, United States
"it's not rocket surgery"
Whatever - guess the old adage" Folks in glass houses shouldn't throw stones" applies here.
  • Posted 11 Oct 2010 20:36
  • Reply by johnr_j
  • Georgia, United States
the job postings for barloworld are not for the atlanta area, they are for the entire barloworld network. and yes, we got rid of dead weight people, techs AND managers.
  • Posted 11 Oct 2010 13:22
  • Reply by grumpy
  • Georgia, United States
Grumpy:
No doubt in my mind the Hyster dealer in Atlanta has changed some folks (including technical types) in the recent past as well. Just take a look at the position openings on this website. Guess this means this also something to consider.
  • Posted 11 Oct 2010 11:06
  • Reply by johnr_j
  • Georgia, United States
something to consider: crown atlanta has been getting rid of their experienced techs for new hires straight out of tech schools, several from MMI out of daytona, and carolina handling let go of several of their experienced techs over the past couple of years. I don't work for either and have nothing negative to say about either product, and have friends at both dealers, but don't rule out hyster's line of AC narrow aisle and pallet units.
  • Posted 11 Oct 2010 06:13
  • Reply by grumpy
  • Georgia, United States
acording with chris_j, the new RR/RD5700 or RR/RD5700S
are the best machines, in AC or DC motors.

by other side, the mast of raymond crack too soon.
and the load wheels are the best against raymond load wheels.

but you are the best judge.
  • Posted 9 Oct 2010 02:44
  • Reply by raul_s
  • San Luis Potosi, Mexico
crown has great support in the area. the new 5700 rr is much improved as well
  • Posted 8 Oct 2010 09:22
  • Reply by chris_j
  • Florida, United States

Post your Reply

Forkliftaction.com accepts no responsibility for forum content and requires forum participants to adhere to the rules. Click here for more information.

Having trouble using the Discussion Forums? Contact us for help.

Upcoming in the editorial calendar
Latest job alerts …
UN Forklift FD30T-NJM1
HANGZHOU, Zhejiang, China
New - Sale
SMV (Konecranes) 16-900C
Balling, Denmark
Used - Sale
Fact of the week
A 1904 lecture by scientist Elie Metchnikoff extolled the benefits of consuming yoghurt for halting the "intestinal putrefaction" which he believed causes aging. The press reported yoghurt as a cure for aging and the ensuing popularity is still with us today.
Upcoming industry events …
May 21-23, 2025 - Guangzhou, China
June 04-05, 2025 - Frankfurt, Germany
September 16-18, 2025 - Dar Es Salaam, Tanzania
Global Industry News
edition #1229 - 8 May 2025
In this week’s Forkliftaction News we look at the financial reports of some of the materials handling industry’s largest players including Hyster-Yale, KION and Hangcha... Continue reading
Fact of the week
A 1904 lecture by scientist Elie Metchnikoff extolled the benefits of consuming yoghurt for halting the "intestinal putrefaction" which he believed causes aging. The press reported yoghurt as a cure for aging and the ensuing popularity is still with us today.