Suits cite patent infringement, personal injury

News Story
- 4 Jun 2009 ( #413 ) - Madison, WI and Philadelphia, PA, United States
2 min read
Raymond has filed suit against Jungheinrich.<br />PHOTO: SHUTTERSTOCK
Raymond has filed suit against Jungheinrich.
PHOTO: SHUTTERSTOCK
Raymond Corp has sued two Jungheinrich entities for patent infringement, while a manager operating a Mitsubishi forklift has taken action against the equipment lessor and manufacturer for personal injury and product liability.

Greene, New York-based Raymond says that the design for the mast construction on the Jungheinrich ETR 320 reach truck infringes US patents that were issued to Raymond in August 2006 and July 2008.

Raymond's patented design for the mast minimises obstruction to a forklift operator's field of view, according to the suit.

Raymond attorneys filed the litigation on 20 May in the US District Court in Madison, demanding a trial by jury and seeking monetary awards from the two defendants, equipment distributor Jungheinrich Lift Truck Corp of Richmond, Virginia and designer-manufacturer Jungheinrich AG of Hamburg, Germany.

Raymond competes directly with Jungheinrich products in the electric forklift truck market.

Attorneys with the Milwaukee, Wisconsin law firm of Quarles & Brady LLP are representing Raymond in the case, which was assigned to Magistrate Judge Stephen L Crocker.

In the other litigation, an attorney says Thomas Catlett was using a Mitsubishi FB18NT to move pallets of muffins to a box truck in a Philadelphia warehouse of his employer, specialty food distributor BT Enterprises Inc, on 7 May 2007.

According to the lawsuit, Catlett "stopped the forklift behind the truck, engaged the emergency brake, dismounted from the forklift and walked to the back of the box truck at which point the forklift rolled into the plaintiff and violently struck him in his back and leg pinning him between the pallet of muffins on the forklift and the truck".

The suit says: "The warning system on the forklift failed to operate when the plaintiff dismounted from the forklift", and Catlett injured his lower back, right knee, calf and leg, and neck and experienced "severe nervous shock".

Catlett sued owner-lessor Accurate Lift Truck Inc of Bethlehem, Pennsylvania and manufacturer Mitsubishi Caterpillar Forklift America Inc (MCFA) of Houston, Texas. An attorney with the Plymouth Meeting, Pennsylvania law firm of Morris Clemm & Heleniak PC filed the suit on 22 April in the US District Court in Philadelphia, asking for a jury trial on the claims of personal injury and product liability. The case was assigned to Judge Stewart Dalzell.

The suit cites more than a dozen examples of the "negligence and carelessness" of Accurate Lift Truck in maintenance, service, safety and standards-compliance matters relating to the forklift. Accurate leased the forklift to BK Enterprises, which employed Catlett as a manager.

MCFA designed and manufactured the electric three-wheel cushion-tyre counterbalanced forklift, which has a lifting capacity of 3,500 pounds (1,575 kg). On 26 May, MCFA asked to be removed from the case.

In 1992, Mitsubishi Group's industrial manufacturing and trading units and a Caterpillar Inc industrial subsidiary pooled their technological and financial resources and established MCFA. The joint venture's plant manufactures Mitsubishi and Caterpillar forklifts in Houston.
OPEX wins patent dispute
OPEX wins patent dispute 11 May 2023 - Moorestown, NJ, United States - 1 min read
Court rules on patent battle
Court rules on patent battle 7 Jul 2022 - London, United Kingdom - 2 min read
JCB to appeal patent ruling
JCB to appeal patent ruling 8 Apr 2021 - Rocester, United Kingdom - 1 min read
Previously about:
Caterpillar gets pact for rough terrain forklifts News Story - 3 Sep 2009 - Peoria, IL, United States - 1 min read
No shows for some News Story - 5 Mar 2009 - International - 3 min read
Briefs News Story - 12 Jun 2008 - 1 min read
Jungheinrich founds corporate venture unit News Story - 10 Apr 2025 - Hamburg, Germany - 1 min read
Jungheinrich records ‘resilient’ results News Story - 16 Aug 2024 - Hamburg, Germany - 1 min read
Jungheinrich UK supports sustainability efforts News Story - 16 Aug 2024 - Cumbria, United Kingdom - 1 min read
Briefs News Story - 22 Dec 2016 - 2 min read
New products News Story - 30 Jun 2016 - 1 min read
New products shown at MODEX News Story - 7 Apr 2016 - Atlanta, GA, United States - 6 min read
Do you have materials handling news? Submit your news here

PREMIUM business

Shenzhen Wellwit Robotics Co., Ltd
The Largest AMR/AGV ODM/OEM Manufacturer in China.

Looking for ambitious dealers worldwide.

Your chance to join the leading forklift lithium battery brand is here.
Exclusive zones are waiting for you! Join BSLBATT's leading innovation in forklift lithium battery technology.
Join hands for success. Enjoy full support and huge profit potential.

Contact us now - www.lithiumforkliftbattery.com 

Words of support …

I know I can count on them. They give valuable suggestions on the campaign planning, and to publish content is as easy as abc, as they take care of the material layout and check links. This is a great support.

Annalisa Castellini, Marketing Manager - Bolzoni S.p.A.

Are you recruiting? Find your ideal candidate among a diverse range of materials handling professionals:

Forkliftaction's JOB MARKET

Looking for ambitious dealers worldwide.

Your chance to join the leading forklift lithium battery brand is here.
Exclusive zones are waiting for you! Join BSLBATT's leading innovation in forklift lithium battery technology.
Join hands for success. Enjoy full support and huge profit potential.

Contact us now - www.lithiumforkliftbattery.com 

PREMIUM business

VETTER Industrie GmbH
The world's most comprehensive range of forks and the most intelligent sensor fork for more safety and efficiency.

Are you recruiting? Find your ideal candidate among a diverse range of materials handling professionals:

Forkliftaction's JOB MARKET

Inside The News
In this week’s Forkliftaction News we wrap up our coverage of ProMat 2025 with a look at some more of the product launches at the Chicago event. We also reveal the new leadership team for Toyota Material Handling North America and which forklift manufacturer has expanded its production from Shanghai... Continue reading

Are you recruiting? Find your ideal candidate among a diverse range of materials handling professionals:

Forkliftaction's JOB MARKET

Transparent, effective, accountable. With Forkliftaction advertising you will know exactly what to expect before the start of your next campaign.

Tell us your objectives and we’ll propose a competitively priced, brand-centred campaign with your CPM* fixed at the campaign’s start. Geo-targeted campaigns available!

For audience statistics and a concise overview of our advertising offer DOWNLOAD our Media Kit.

* CPM = Cost-Per-Thousand impressions