MORRIS SUES KONECRANES FOR UNFAIR COMPETITION

News Story
- 23 Oct 2003 ( #130 ) - OAK CREEK, WI, United States
2 min read
Morris Material Handling Inc has sued KCI Konecranes International PLC for "egregious and systematic violation" of intellectual property and "acts of unfair competition".

The suit was filed on October 7 in the US District Court in Milwaukee, Wisconsin. The complaints include infringement and unfair competition related to federal, state and common-law trademark protections; false advertising; and fraudulent representation under a Wisconsin statute.

Plaintiffs include privately-held Oak Creek-based Morris Material Handling, subsidiaries SPH Crane & Hoist Inc, of Milwaukee, MHE Technologies Inc, of Wilmington, Delaware, and affiliated licensor Harnischfeger Technologies Inc, also of Wilmington.

Morris was founded in the 1880s as an operating division of Harnischfeger Corp, in Milwaukee, and, during the mid-1990s, was known as the P&H Crane Division. In March 1998, Harnischfeger sold 80% of the division, which adopted the Morris identity.

Morris has an exclusive licence from Harnischfeger to use the P&H trademark in the industrial crane and hoist business.

Publicly-traded KCI Konecranes, based in Hyvinkää, Finland, has major global overhead crane and hoist operations, including its US unit, fellow defendant KCI Konecranes Inc, of Springfield, Ohio. The parent company had profit of EUR24.6 million (USD25.8 million) on 2002 sales of EUR713.6 million (USD748.1 million) and, at December 31, employed 4,441 persons.

Morris alleges Konecranes and affiliates misused the P&H trademark in Canada in September 1999, misused the Morris trademark in Canada in December 2001 and distributed inappropriate marketing material and passed off non-P&H aftermarket parts as genuine P&H parts in April 2003.

Morris said it complained in letters to Konecranes management. In response, Konecranes "denied undertaking any wrongful conduct", the Morris suit said. "Defendants and their affiliates have continued to misuse and misappropriate plaintiffs' intellectual rights, all for the purpose (of) diverting business and customers" from Morris to Konecranes. Numerous examples are cited in the litigation.

The suit identifies three Konecranes-related websites on which Morris trademarks are listed.

Morris has requested a jury trial and intends to pursue an award for punitive damages and "actual damages to be proven at trial", the suit said. Initially, Morris wants the court to prevent Konecranes from continuing the alleged actions.

The suit said Konecranes' US market expansion had included purchases of "Shepard Niles, Crane Manufacturing and Kranco". In addition, Konecranes "has aggressively but unsuccessfully attempted to purchase all or portions of the Morris Group on several occasions since 1997", according to the suit.

Konecranes had not responded to the suit before deadline.
Court reduces forklift accident fine
Court reduces forklift accident fine 18 Jul 2024 - Birmingham, United Kingdom - 1 min read
Companies fined over forklift tech injuries at Pirelli Tyres
Companies fined over forklift tech injuries at Pirelli Tyres 16 May 2024 - Carlisle, United Kingdom - 2 min read
Previously about:
Dragados repeats RTG order News Story - 24 Aug 2006 - HYVINKÄÄ, Finland - 1 min read
Movers & Shakers News Story - 10 Aug 2006 - 1 min read
Movers & Shakers News Story - 6 Jul 2006 - 1 min read
Konecranes closes Windsor factory News Story - 10 Jun 2010 - Windsor, WI, United States - 1 min read
Do you have materials handling news? Submit your news here
Inside The News
This week Forkliftaction News is celebrating its 25th anniversary! A wonderful achievement given we launched at a time when just 6% of the world’s population were internet users, according to Internet World Stats . Over the coming weeks, we will be sharing stories about our history and rolling out more celebrations, so keep an eye out... Continue reading

It’s the year 2000. You’re in front of a boxy beige desktop waiting for the screeching ramblings of your dial-up to reach its finale. You go to Yahoo!, MSN, or maybe AOL, and start the mind-numbing process of finding your very specific needle in the digital haystack. And with web pages loading one image at a time, patience isn’t just a virtue – it’s a requirement!

As clumsy as this early iteration seems now, this technology was the great enabler that allowed Forkliftaction to connect to the industry across the globe.  

To everyone who has connected with Forkliftaction in the past 25 years, thank you for your contribution to our success! We feel deeply touched by your words of encouragement.

What has Forkliftaction meant to you? Drop us a line.

Words of support …

Undoubtedly, peer experience plays a crucially important role in our industry and it is extremely valuable for us to be part of the platform, where industry professionals, as well as end users can discuss and learn more about the materials handling world.

Alexandra Artemova, Marketing Specialist

Are you recruiting? Find your ideal candidate among a diverse range of materials handling professionals:

Forkliftaction's JOB MARKET

Since July 2000, Forkliftaction News has been your guide to the developments that are shaping your industry.

Starting today we are also looking back on some of the key news stories from our extensive news archive.

In the news email and on the website, you'll see links to stories that were 'leading our news' multiple years ago, with topics spanning world-first products, big acquisitions, and major industry shifts.
We hope you enjoy this unique insight into the materials handling industry!

PREMIUM business

Tailift Material Handling USA Inc
Part of Toyota Industries Group - Leading manufacturer of High-quality machines.

Are you recruiting? Find your ideal candidate among a diverse range of materials handling professionals:

Forkliftaction's JOB MARKET

Since July 2000, Forkliftaction News has been your guide to the developments that are shaping your industry.

Starting today we are also looking back on some of the key news stories from our extensive news archive.

In the news email and on the website, you'll see links to stories that were 'leading our news' multiple years ago, with topics spanning world-first products, big acquisitions, and major industry shifts.
We hope you enjoy this unique insight into the materials handling industry!