Report this forum post

There's been a lot of news recently about fuel cells in the material handling industry. I'd like to clear up some misconceptions for the different types of fuel cells available for material handling equipment. I haven't had much exposure to the fuel cells for class 1 equipment, but know that when they are in use, they function well. I've had much more exposure to the fuel cells for class III vehicles from Plug Power and Oorja Protonics. I can say that fuel cells from both companies perform very well, they just go about it differently.

Plug Powers units are hydrogen based and uses highly compressed hydrogen as the fuel source. The unit replaces/eliminates the need for a battery and supplies power for all the vehicle needs. Oorja Protonics units use a liquid alcohol fuel cell at ambient pressure as the fuel source. It's roughly a third the size of the Plug unit and works in conjunction with the existing battery. Per my knowledge, both should fit on most, if not all class III vehicles with battery compartment designed to hold 12-****-13 batteries. However, if the Plug fuel cell unit goes down the vehicle is down; if the Oorja unit goes down, the battery will still be there to power the vehicle. Both take about a minute to refill, Plug with compressed hydrogen and Oorja with liquid alcohol.

Both technologies are new and as with the migration from ICE, it'll take some time to proliferate. I encourage anyone thinking about new class III equipment to look into fuel cell as they are available today.

Oorja has a quick ROI even without subsidies and Plug has lots of government (federal and state) money to help with implementation. I'm not versed in fire and safety codes regarding compressed hydrogen, but I believe with the alcohol fuel, permitting for indoor use is very straight forward.

Hope this clears up some of the confusion and stoke some interest in fuel cells.
  • Posted 29 May 2009 07:21
  • By vlee
  • joined 29 May'09 - 1 message
  • California, United States

This is ONLY to be used to report flooding, spam, advertising and problematic (harassing, abusive or crude) posts.

Indicates mandatory field
Mitsubishi FGE35AT
Yokohama, Japan
Used - Sale
Ncn 85TH
Ncn 85TH 2014
Balling, Denmark
Used - Sale
Latest job alerts …
Indianapolis, IN, United States
Saratoga, United States
East Syracuse, United States
Columbia, SC, United States
Fact of the week
The use of "hello" as a telephone greeting is attributed to Thomas Edison. He is said to have suggested it as a simpler alternative to other greetings, such as "Do I get you?" or "Are you there?".
Fact of the week
The use of "hello" as a telephone greeting is attributed to Thomas Edison. He is said to have suggested it as a simpler alternative to other greetings, such as "Do I get you?" or "Are you there?".

PREMIUM business

Lift Tek Elecar
Global leader in the design and manufacture of masts, carriages, integral sideshifters & fork positioners.