Discussion:
MCFA Relationship Strained?

Heard a rumour that the Caterpillar Mitsubishi relationship may be going through some changes. Any truth? Saw a new 5000lb electric cat that was made in Finland. Anyone have any info?

Doc.
  • Posted 13 Jan 2005 14:14
  • Discussion started by NTOLERANCE
  • Wisconsin, United States
Showing items 16 - 30 of 32 results.
If you really want to know something about it old towmotorque I may be able to help. I sold these in the early 60's.
I saw one of the old dial indicator finger set up plates around our shop a year or so ago. It was great on flat ground but had no torque multification like the clark H225, but you could not wear it out in a warehouse. Had a lot of hesitation that everyone disliked. jsut let me know at [email address removed]
  • Posted 18 Dec 2005 15:52
  • Reply by LT40
  • Tennessee, United States
Mr. Etharp:
Thanks very much for your quick response and offer to help me. When I have a more specific technical problem or question I will try and contact you. I am new to the BB and did not realize the email address would be taken out.
The reason I thought I would try and locate a factory service manual is it would help me alng the way whebn I am doing the restoration. I plan to disassessemble the machine and remove the engine and transmission in hopes to overhaul them.

In that I have the other two manuals I mentioned, I wanted to learn if Caterpillar or MCF ever printed a Service Manual. I did locate some service information on Microfiche that MCH contracted (I think) with the Bell and Howell Media firm to produce covering the Towmotor, but I was disappointed in that it was not very complete like the Printed Parts Manual I obtained from MCF. It was suggested that I try to contact some of the older dealers that might have some old manuals left over from the "Towmotor Years". Anyway thanks again for your reply and offer to help.
Respectfully
jamesemu (Jim) Musick in
Chicago Park, CA 95712
  • Posted 16 Dec 2005 11:44
  • Reply by jamesemu
  • California, United States
Gentlemen:
I am a novice as compared to all of the experienced persons posting the history related to Caterpillar and I have read these with great interest. As my favorite term "Towmotor" was mentioned I thought I might explain what I am trying to do with an older model Towmotor.
I am in the process of restoring it for personal use here on our farm.
The Model is of the 601P Series and has the somewhat unusual "ToMoTorque" Transmission.
My reason for telling all of this is I hoped that some of the older Gentlemem here might be familiar with this treasured old Forklift and be able to tell me if there is anywhere they might know of where I might locate a copy of a Factory Service Manual. I was able to locate a manual n the Transmission and a very complete Parts Manual from "MCF", but have been told there at one time was a General Service Manual published. MCF said they are out of print and my best chance of finding one (even one that I might photocopy), would be from the library of a shop or mechanic that might have saved one from years ago?
I appreciate hearing from anyone having any "leads", to send me an email at: [email address removed]
Thank you very much for any help any one can offer.
Jim (jamesemu)
  • Posted 16 Dec 2005 04:36
  • Reply by jamesemu
  • California, United States
Hey SKIPPER - You sound like you might know.... who is the Eng Mngr over hydraulics at MCFA. Or.... does anyone else know? Thanks!
  • Posted 21 Oct 2005 23:25
  • Reply by shower
  • Wisconsin, United States
Mat 03: that's a typical statement from a guy who only see's yellow, to say Nissan took the cheap route is ridiculous.We've put them side by side and they are both solid for today's standards.
The only real difference is that there aren't any Cat components on the Cat except for the yellow paint.
If you want a Nissan power plant you buy a Nissan not a copy cat.
I mean when you go buy a Chev do you request a Ford power plant?
Explain to me where you got your info from.
  • Posted 13 Aug 2005 00:52
  • Reply by Gordo
  • Alberta, Canada
Through the years, since 1992 (CAT/Mit join venture started), CAT has reduced their ownership of MCFA from nearly 20% to about (or bellow) 10%. It will be interesting how this evolves in the comming years. Caterpillar Inc. does not allow MCFA to use the Caterpillar name, the "official" name is CAT Lift Trucks and they can use the CAT logo

The 3000 lbs-7000lbs pneumatics, and The 3000 lbs-6000lbs cushions, are not identical to the Nissan Platinum series, but the only difference is in the mast, the control unit for the truck functions, which also interacts with the fuel system and a few other cosmetic items. The Nissan 8000lbs-10000lbs pneumatics are built in Houston by MCFA. The masts for of these trucks are built in house, except for the quad, which is supplied by Liftek.

The new line of class II trucks, the chassis in made by Rocla and the mast by Liftek. Class III, I am not sure if they finally made a decision to go with Jungheinrich in some of their models.

Like other manufacturers of more than one brand, in MCFA the internal relationship is good, they wear different hats and shirts whenever they have to, and they do it in harmony.

The 4G63 and 4G64 was really built by Mitsubishi motors not MHI, diesel engines, S4S and S6S are built by MHI. The 4G63 and 64 got to the point that they were not cost efective. The Nissan TB42 is probably being used in some of the large pnumatic trucks.

In addition to the CAT/Mit. name brands, they revided the Towmotor, I have seen very few, so, I do not know if it was just a one time thing or just a market research project.

CAT, Mitsubishi, Rocla, Nissan, Towmotor... are we confused or what ??
  • Posted 12 Aug 2005 00:36
  • Reply by Av_Joe
  • South Carolina, United States
you are correct with the Integral sideshifter, Liftech does make it.
As far as the 4G64 MHI has always made it. Who do you think makes it?
  • Posted 10 Jun 2005 01:17
  • Reply by mat03
  • Texas, United States
As a Cat Dealer Principal this discussion is very intresting to me because there are so many misconceptions.
First off, the new Nissan forklift is not the same at all. The early stages of the product were developed together so the styling is similar. The engine and transmission are the same and that is it. After these two parts, Nissan took a cost cutting approach and MCFA lived up to the Cat name. Some major differences are: the stronger mast in the Cat, one piece headguard on the Cat, and the software that controls the engine.
The mast deflection in the Nissan is the worst in the industry; and all the Mit/Cat masts are made in Houston with the trucks - the only LiftTech mast that is put on a Cat truck is the quad mast for counterbalanced and the mast for the Narrow Isle Reach truck (NR3000-NR4500). (Frame-Rocla & Mast-LiftTech then they are assembled in Houston).

To clarify some of the other statements: MHI still makes the 4G64 engine, a majority of the MCFA employees are old Cat guys, there is no bad blood between Cat, Mit, or MCFA, and the 8000-11000 Nissan truck is built in Houston by MCFA for Nissan.
  • Posted 4 Jun 2005 06:14
  • Reply by mat03
  • Texas, United States
The CAT truck you saw which said made in Finland is correct. All European warehouse equipment made for CAT was manufactured by Rocla of Finland. Have a look at there website, they make some excellent machines. The original machines where NRS35 etc, then NR3000. I have manuals on these trucks as i used to work for CAT UK. They carry a full range of warehouse equipment. I recently saw an AC powered reach truck in North Carolina and what a nice machine it was. If they unleash the whole range into the US it could be very interesting for the competition.
  • Posted 29 Apr 2005 12:14
  • Reply by denis_r
  • South Carolina, United States
Hi, NTOLERANCE

I'm sure you have read the news letter #193 of Jan.27. MCFA(Mitsu-Cat-Fork-Ame) is the largest share holder of Rocla (30.8% by '02 Dec, see their HP). I understand Caterpiller is just lending MCFA their brand/logo and receives brand fee.

Mitsubishi and Nissan jointly developped their latest model (speculated to be once and the last), thus there are many common components in these models.

Caterpillar seems to have no interest in Lift Truck business to me. And I hear no bad relation talks of Caterpillar-Mitsubishi construction equipment company in Japan. Their business scale of earth-moving equipment is far greater than their lift truck business.

I am still interested the subject you have raised, keep us informed.
  • Posted 4 Feb 2005 15:19
  • Reply by tate_i
  • Tokyo, Japan
I saw this on an old press release:

" Rocla Oyj and Mitsubishi Caterpillar Forklift Europe B.V. (MCFE) have concluded an exclusive agreement by which Rocla takes up representation of Caterpillar counterbalance trucks in Finland, Estonia and Russia as of January 2002."

Here is the URL
http://www.pressi.com/int/release/40847.html
  • Admin
  • Posted 31 Jan 2005 13:31
  • Reply by Admin
  • Queensland, Australia
The Nissan Platinum and MCFA are not identical, the fuel and engine management systems are different. The Cat and the Mitsi have only used the block and some frame parts. The Nissan has the five piece overhead guard MCFA is one piece, Counterweight is different, Mast in the MCFA is lesser quality, and the seat in the Nissan is a suspension seat, an extra $300.00 hit on the MCFA trucks. Nissan has a good thing with this Platinum truck, they would never give away the keys.
  • Posted 22 Jan 2005 05:55
  • Reply by Scout
  • Alberta, Canada
The plot thickens.....

Aparanty there is an issue of someone else building a narrow isle reach truck for one of the two and not the other. I will get more details in the coming week.
  • Posted 16 Jan 2005 05:18
  • Reply by NTOLERANCE
  • Wisconsin, United States
Have you compared the new Mitsu/Cat 5000 lbs pneumatic to the new Nissan Platinium 5000 lbs pneumatic. Except for the colors and some details it is the same lift that is made by Nissan. So the new question now is where does Nissan fit in this Mitsu/Cat deal ????????
  • Posted 14 Jan 2005 23:13
  • Reply by diesel
  • Quebec, Canada
Cat did build a lift. Originally, Towmotor. Later changed to the full Cat name. Early truck such as the old M40 series were updated (heavily) Tomotors. Later Cat built the truck that would eventually become the Daewoo. Cat had at some point and time, contracted Daewoo to build the Cat trucks for North America (we US at least) Later after the Cat / Misti deal Daewoo ended up selling the Relabeled Cat truck.

Thats a pretty rough history, I may be off a few details.

Mitsi stopped using a 3.0 v in ther larger trucks (6000lb capacity and higher some years ago in favor of the GM 4.3 Vortec v6. ( I think it was cost and reliability issues.) The 3.0 Mitsi engine was the same engine used in Chrysler/Dodge/Plymouth minvans and some cars. Although the engine was tuned and built for industrial applications. other reasons for the 3.0-4.3 change may have been brand recognition, how many people have a 4.3 in their SUV or pickup?

As far as the change to the Nissan engine, I cannot elaborate. Havent worked for a Mistsi dealer in a number of years. But I can say, that in my experience, MCFA of Houston, doent make a change unless is positively affects the bottom line.

Heard the Possible Cat Mitsi issues from a Cat dealer employee. Take it for what its worth. His statement was Cat was unhappy.

Doc.
  • Posted 14 Jan 2005 15:31
  • Reply by NTOLERANCE
  • Wisconsin, United States
The things I do can cause a person to get hurt expelled arrested even deported. Dont try it at home

Post your Reply

Forkliftaction.com accepts no responsibility for forum content and requires forum participants to adhere to the rules. Click here for more information.

Having trouble using the Discussion Forums? Contact us for help.

TCM FD80Z7
TCM FD80Z7 1990
Yokohama, Japan
Used - Sale
Mitsubishi FGE35AT
Yokohama, Japan
Used - Sale
Upcoming industry events …
May 21-23, 2025 - Guangzhou, China
June 04-05, 2025 - Frankfurt, Germany
September 16-18, 2025 - Dar Es Salaam, Tanzania
Yale GDP100M
Flesherton, Ontario, Canada
Used - Sale
SMV (Konecranes) 16-1200C
Balling, Denmark
New - Sale
Upcoming industry events …
May 21-23, 2025 - Guangzhou, China
June 04-05, 2025 - Frankfurt, Germany
September 16-18, 2025 - Dar Es Salaam, Tanzania
Movers & Shakers
Jospeh E Creed Jospeh E Creed
CEO, Caterpillar Inc
Secretary general, European Rental Association
Chairman of the Board of Directors, UgoWork
vice president, Investor Relations, Konecranes
TCM FD115-3
Yokohama, Japan
Used - Sale
Taylor T520M
Coraopolis, Pennsylvania, United States
Used - Sale & Hire
Latest job alerts …