Discussion:
Battery & Charger, is there best in class or is it personal preference

With an electric truck (NA & CB) fleet in the US market; Is there an industry leader and ranking or does brand/style boil down to customer preference to battery and battery dealer?
  • Posted 9 Apr 2008 21:00
  • By nMississippi
  • joined 16 Jan'08 - 2 messages
  • Tennessee, United States
Showing items 1 - 2 of 2 results.
There are differences in battery construction and durability but they don't always translate to productivity for the trucks. If the application demand is light and there is a short life expectancy (3 year lease) you will probably never see any difference. If you want to own batteries for 5-7 years and/ or have a demanding application (temperature, floor, utilization) a cheap battery will typically give you some issues in time. Good local service can make any battery design flaws transparent. Poor local service hurts even the largest brands in some areas. Based strictly on engineering, self reported quality and consistency the best in class are Deka and C&D C line
  • Posted 22 Apr 2008 23:44
  • By The_mush
  • joined 27 Feb'08 - 6 messages
  • United States
There are differences for sure.
I've had good luck, over the years,with C&D & GNB.
For batteries, the best piece of advice I can offer, is to shy away from the yuasa products, especially HUP.

(I base this on ~20 years of fighting and repairing them.)

Chargers are a little greyer. The most important thing, is to make sure that the chargers have high enough output to properly charge the battery.(too little will cause sulfation)
The next most important thing is the charger controls. The charger needs to to use DV/DT (difference in voltage/ difference in time) to properly detect battery charge state.
Some chargers simply look for a peak voltage, then start a 3 hour timer to shut-down. (ie. hup auto1000's) These will work fine, only so long as the battery is in perfect condition.

All that being said, make sure you can get parts and service for the equipment.
  • Posted 11 Apr 2008 02:54
  • By mike_n
  • joined 11 Feb'06 - 138 messages
  • Alberta, Canada

Post your Reply

Forkliftaction accepts no responsibility for forum content and requires forum participants to adhere to our rules of conduct. Click here for more information.

If you are having trouble using the Discussion Forums, please contact us for help.

Movers & Shakers
Todd J Doxsee Todd J Doxsee
National dealer development manager, Castle Equipment Company
Sales operations, Heli
Chief financial officer, Cyngn
Executive vice president and chief commercial officer, East Penn Manufacturing
Fact of the week
Brothers Adolf ("Adi") and Rudolf ("Rudi") Dassler split their shoe company after WWII due to a bitter feud, and established the rival companies of Adidas and Puma. Their personal animosity and business rivalry divided their German hometown Herzogenaurach. The town became known as "the town of bent necks" due to the intense loyalty to each brand.
Latest job alerts …
Prospect CT, United States
Philadelphia, United States
Dayton OH/Cincinnati OH, United States
Davenport, IA, United States